Worldwide icon-chevron-right North America icon-chevron-right United States icon-chevron-right New York State icon-chevron-right New York icon-chevron-right The best new winter cocktails in NYC

The best new winter cocktails in NYC

From a Japanese toddy to a Jewish punch, New York's best new winter cocktails in will warm your cold bones right up

BAR GOTO toddy
Photograph: Paul Wagtouicz Bar Goto
By Dan Q Dao |
Advertising

As winter arrives and snow once again covers New York, we turn to the restaurants and best bars in NYC for a warm relief. Whether its snugging into bars with fireplaces or sipping comforting seasonal quaffs, there's nothing better than a toasty booze blanket to fend off the frosty air. This year, warm your bones with the best new winter cocktails in New York—from a sake-based eggnog remix to a soup-inspired Israeli punch.

Best new winter cocktails in NYC

BAR GOTO toddy
Photograph: Paul Wagtouicz
Bars, Izakaya

Yuzu-Apple Toddy at Bar Goto

icon-location-pin Lower East Side

Kenta Goto gives the classic toddy Far East–flavor enhancers at his Japanese cocktail bar. A base of lemon-ginger tea is spiked with sharp, sweet calvados apple brandy and swirled with honey and fresh-squeezed lemon juice in a blue-and-white ceramic bowl. Temper the glass to your preference with dollops of bright yuzu-infused marmalade, spooned from a matching side dish. $15.

Restaurants, Italian

Mirtillo Martini at L'Amico

icon-location-pin Midtown West

At Laurent Tourondel's Italian-inflected American restaurant in the Eventi Hotel, the classic martini gets a seasonal tweak, bundling up with sweet cranberries and herbaceous rosemary for the winter. The gin of choice is London's Ford, while the vermouth is an Italian Carpano Antica. $14.

Advertising
Noche Buena from Leyenda
Photograph: Andrew Kist
Bars, Cocktail bars

Noche Buena at Leyenda

icon-location-pin Boerum Hill

Julie Reiner and Ivy Mix’s Carroll Gardens coctelería spotlights the tradition of post-dinner sherry and coffee in this spirits-forward drink, crafted by Mix’s protégé Amanda de la Nuez. Inspired by Christmas Eve in Cuba (noche buena translates to “good night” in Spanish), the cup gets its kick courtesy of Black Bottle Scotch and Plantation Jamaica rum, offset by a potent splash of Heering coffee liqueur and a froth of egg white. Grated nutmeg, cinnamon and an espresso bean top off the festive sip. $12.

MOTHER OF PEARL gloppy fizz cocktail
Photograph: Paul Wagtouicz
Bars, Cocktail bars

Gloppy Fizz at Mother of Pearl

icon-location-pin East Village

Give tiki a cold-weather twist with barkeep Laura Newman’s Foxon Park birch beer fizz, doubling up on rum with aged Gosling’s and Hamilton Jamaican Pot Still Black. Channeling a sunny escape in the dead of winter, the drink employs traditional warm-weather flavors—chocolate mole bitters, pineapple and lime juices, and cinnamon-smacked R. Jelínek fernet—crowned with a bouquet of absinthe-sprayed mint sprigs. It will almost make you forget the impending snowfalls to come—almost. $15.

Advertising
Sakenog at Piora
Photograph: Michael Tulipan
Restaurants, Contemporary American

Sakegg-Nog at Piora

icon-location-pin West Village

At the West Village's Michelin-starred mainstay, head bartender Shinya Yamao slings a Japanese twist on traditional eggnog. Nigori, or unfiltered, sake forms the base, layered with a rich blend of soy milk, sugar, vanilla beans and egg yolk. The ingredients are shaken together with ice before being strained into a coupé and the drink can be served hot upon request. $16.

Fireside Chat at Porchlight
Photograph: Filip Wolak
Bars, Cocktail bars

Fireside Chat at Porchlight

icon-location-pin Chelsea

It’s all in the name: Head bartender Nick Bennett’s room-temperature quaff recalls the soul-warming comforts of by-the-hearth boozing with malty Bols Genever, fortifying herbal Becherovka bitters and almond-laced amaretto, with a nuttiness that’s nicely rounded out by a spoonful of walnut liqueur. And like many of Bennett’s hallmark potables, it’s conveniently stored on-tap and only poured into a brandy snifter upon service. $15.

Advertising
THE BENNETT good evening spitfire
Photograph: Paul Wagtouicz
Bars, Cocktail bars

Good Evening, Spitfire at The Bennett

icon-location-pin Tribeca

All the comforts of warm hot cocoa—even the cozy mug—are found in this surprisingly cold, coconut-milk–based cup by bar director Meaghan Dorman. Inspired by a spicy coffee libation she had at New Orleans' famed Spitfire (hence the name), Dorman soothes stiff Vida mezcal with a dash of Bittermens chocolate mole bitters, and spices it with boisterous Ancho Reyes chile liqueur, a bar spoon of cinnamon syrup and a crown of grated nutmeg. $15.

Warm Tzimmes Punch at Timna
Photograph: Michael Tulipan
Restaurants, Mediterranean

Warm Tzimmes Punch at Timna

icon-location-pin East Village

Tzimmes, a sweet Ashkenazic Rosh Hashanah stew traditionally made with root vegetables and dried fruits, is the inspiration for Amir Nathan’s carrot-whispered punch. In this spiked rendition, the root is candied as a floating garnish as well as infused with cardamom to yield an aromatic syrup, brightening a blend of Ironstone Vineyards merlot and a 10-year-aged port. $12.

Advertising
False Witness at The Up and Up
Photograph: Matt Piacentini
Bars, Cocktail bars

False Witness at The Up & Up Bar

icon-location-pin West Village

Descend into this subterranean Macdougal Street den for a seriously stiff winter cocktail from owner-bartender Matt Piacentini. The spirits-forward concoction fuses a mix of Vermont-sourced Whistle Pig rye, Atlantico Reserve rum, Jägermeister and grappa, barely tamed with a splash of pistachio orgeat and a sprinkle of nutmeg. The stiffer the drink, the warmer you get. Right? $14.

Venue says Craft cocktail bar hidden away in a historic space in Manhattan's Greenwich Village.

Bars, Gastropubs

Gunfire on Orchard at Wassail

icon-location-pin Lower East Side

Jennifer Lim and Ben Sandler's cider-soaked boite feels like the cool-weather months all year round, with dozens of drafts and nearly 100 bottles of the apple elixir on offer at any time. For the winter, head bartender Jade Sotack crafts a traditional wassail (a Norse mulled cider), tweaked with one of her favorite ingredients, Madeira. The drink fuses that fortified Portuguese wine with equal parts sweet and Scrumpy cider, along with bourbon, pear brandy and a dash of Angostura, all topped with a clove-studded citrus peel. $13.

More to explore

Advertising