Worldwide icon-chevron-right North America icon-chevron-right United States icon-chevron-right New York State icon-chevron-right New York icon-chevron-right The 13 best Halloween theater events in 2019
Blackout
Photograph: Courtesy Blackout

The 13 best Halloween theater events in 2019

Travel to dark places for Halloween at these 13 creepy New York City stage shows in 2019

By Adam Feldman
Advertising

Halloween is the most theatrical of American holidays. Every year, people of all ages and from all walks of life put on costumes and makeup and bring the world of make-believe to the streets—and the theater world, for its part, is happy to join the fun with a range of Halloween shows to celebrate the season. We’ve scared up this list of the 13 best horror-themed events, from Off Broadway to way Off-Off Broadway, to help you get in the spirit.

RECOMMENDED: The best Halloween events for 2019 in NYC

A picture of the Couchbound email

An email you’ll actually love

Sign up to our Couchbound newsletter and bring the city to your sofa

Subscribe now

13 Halloween Theater Events

All Hallows Eve
Photograph: Courtesy Richard Termine

All Hallows Eve

Theater Musicals

Young twin siblings wage war with a demoness in this original Halloween musical by Martin P. Robinson, who created the original Audrey II puppet for Little Shop of Horrors. In addition to directing and designing the show, Robinson has written its book; the music is by Sesame Street's Paul Rudolph. Don't bring little kiddies: This show has dark tricks up its sleeve.

Blackout
Photograph: Courtesy of the artist

Blackout

Theater Interactive

Josh Randall and Kristjan Thor's scary Halloween attraction returns to New York for a 10th-anniversary production. Don't even think about bringing a partner—you have to go through it solo, with a protective mask and a flashlight. The descent into darkness involves lots of tight spaces as well as simulated sexual and violent situations. While speaking is not allowed inside, screaming is more than welcome. (Don’t worry, they give you a safe word to use if you need to exit early.)

Advertising
The Changeling
Photograph: Courtesy Montgomery Sutton

The Changeling

Theater Drama

The Queens company Rude Grooms, which staged The Witch of Edmonton for Halloween last year, now takes a stab at Thomas Middleton and William Rowley’s challengingly constructed Jacobean tragedy, a sordid 1622 tale of unchastity, murder and deception. Audiences are encouraged to dress in costume, and can choose between seeing this immersive production in a speakeasy-ish bar at the Astorian or at the larger Plaxall Gallery. 

The Glass Menagerie
Photograph: Courtesy Chris Loupos

The Glass Menagerie

Theater Drama

Directors Austin Pendleton and Peter Bloch give a horror-movie twist to this latest revival of Tennessee Williams's sad 1944 memory play, in which a fading Southern belle takes a toll on her wallflower daughter and secretive son. Expect spooky touches of the surreal.

Advertising
John Kevin Jones in Killing An Evening With Edgar Allen Poe
Photograph: Courtesy Joey Stocks

Killing an Evening with Edgar Allan Poe

Theater Drama

John Kevin Jones, whose annual performance of A Christmas Carol at the Merchant's House Museum has become something of a local tradition, expands into Halloween territory with this solo performance (directed by Rhonda Dodd) of works by 19th-century scare king Edgar Allan Poe. In a funereal, candlelit parlor, Jones shares "The Tell-Tale Heart," "The Pit and the Pendulum," "The Cask of Amontillado" and, of course, "The Raven."

I Can't See
Photograph: Courtesy Russ Rowland

I Can't See

Theater Interactive

Equipped with audio headsets and then plunged into total darkness, audiences feel their way through a potentially terrifying series of events in the latest Halloween-ready show by Tim Haskell, the man behind the immersive horror-theater events Nightmare and This Is Real. The plot is inspired by W.W. Jacobs's 1909 ghost story, "The Toll-House." 

Advertising
Jonathan Groff in Little Shop of Horrors
Photograph: Courtesy Emilio Madrid-Kuse

Little Shop of Horrors

Theater Musicals Westside Theatre, Hell's Kitchen

Jonathan Groff, Tammy Blanchard and Christian Borle star in the latest revival of Alan Menken and Howard Ashman's dark, sweet, tuneful and utterly winsome 1982 horror-camp musical about a flesh-eating plant who makes dreams come true for a lowly flower-shop worker. Michael Mayer directs the feeding frenzy.

Clay McLeod Chapman in The Pumpkin Pie Show
Photograph: Courtesy Antonia Stoyanovich

The Pumpkin Pie Show: The Remaking

Theater Drama

Horror-drunk storytelling virtuoso Clay McLeod Chapman gave us a good scare in 2017 when he announced that his brilliant and hyperliterary thriller series, the Pumpkin Pie Show, would be ending after 20 years. Happily, he's had a change of heart—and what kind of horror figure stays dead anyhow? This year, Chapman spins the tale of a mother and daughter burned at the stake for witchcraft but not quite reconciled to staying in the coffin. (Each audience member will receive a free copy of Chapman’s new novel, The Remaking.)

Advertising
The Séance Machine
Photograph: Courtesy Brandon James Gwinn

The Séance Machine

Theater Drama

A posssibly mad scientist demonstrates her latest invention—a machine that lets you hear voices from beyond the grave—in this original horror show by EllaRose Chary and Brandon James Gwinn, who curate the monthly alt-musical showcase Tank-aret. Julia Sears directs the premiere.

Sleep No More
Photograph: Courtesy Yaniv Schulman

Sleep No More

4 out of 5 stars
Theater Interactive McKittrick Hotel, Chelsea
Open run

Punchdrunk’s dark, sleek, gorgeous installation is awe-inspiring in both its size and detail. Silent audience members in creepy white masks are set free in a six-floor labyrinth of wonders, while roving attractive actor-dancers plays out enigmatic scenes inspired by Macbeth and Hitchcock. As is its wont, the show is throwing lavish Halloween parties on October 25, 26 and 31.

Advertising
Natalie Hegg in Hunger Thirst Theatre's Strangers in the Night
Photograph: Courtesy Philip Estrera

Strangers in the Night

Theater Experimental

Hunger & Thirst Theatre runs up to Halloween with a pair of creepy one-acts: Patricia Lynn's Screwed, a murder story loosely inspired by Henry James's The Turn of the Screw; and Emily Kitchen's fantastical Bottling Dreams of the Tearful Don't-Knower, in which a man searches a haunted forest for a pool of tears.

Luke Williams as Dick Johnson
Photograph: Courtesy of the artist

The Wake of Dick Johnson

Theater Experimental

A dead man rises at his wake to explain the terrors of the afterworld in this immersive show, written and performed by Luke Walker. The musical duo Okapi plays its original score on cello and double bass.

Advertising
Who Killed Edgar Allan Poe? The Cooping Theory 1969
Photograph: Courtesy Michael Gallo

Who Killed Edgar Allan Poe? The Cooping Theory 1969

Theater Interactive

Poseidon Theatre Company, led by director Aaron Salazar, invites audiences to an immersive mystery that investigates the enigmatic 1849 death of horror master Edgar Allan Poe. The show—written by Nate Raven and featuring original music by Manuel Pelayo and Giancarlo Bonfati—is set in 1969 and spans multiple rooms in the retro karaoke warren RPM Underground; food and drinks add to the spooky-festive experience.

Recommended

    You may also like

      Advertising