Patsy Grimaldi—the flour-dusted legend behind Grimaldi's, which has since changed hands—busts out of retirement to reclaim his pie shop's first location, along with its original coal oven. Your whole brood is more than welcome—pizza has, after all, been in Patsy's family for eight generations. The menu spotlights iconic red-sauce fare, including classic pies (Margherita, white pizza) and desserts ranging from the classic cannoli to a proprietary chocolate-and-raspberry flavor from nearby Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory. To top it all off, the antique jukebox playing Patsy's favorite Sinatra tunes might make you feel like you're a part of the pizzaiolo's family, yourself.
19 Old Fulton St
|Cross street:||between Front and Water Sts|
|Opening hours:||Daily 11am–11pm|
|Transport:||Subway: A, C to High St|
|Price:||Average pie: $17. AmEx, Disc, MC, V|