News

Broadway review: Now You See Me Live

Four magicians take the stage in a pageant of mystification by the creators of The Illusionists.

Adam Feldman
Written by
Adam Feldman
Theater and Dance Editor, Time Out USA
Now You See Me Live
Photograph: Courtesy Jeremy Daniel | Now You See Me Live
Advertising

Broadway review by Adam Feldman
Rating: Not recommended
Ticketing: Buy tickets here

Broadway has embraced magic warmly in the past 20 years, whether performed by big stars like Penn and Teller and Derren Brown or by slates of tricksters with specialty skills in multiple incarnations of The Illusionists, created by Simon Painter and produced by Tim Lawson. The latest edition of the latter series is Now You See Me Live, a mixed-bill and mixed-bag spectacle co-created with Illusionists mainstay Adam Trent. Should you see it? That depends. 

Darcy Oake in Now You See Me Live
Photograph: Courtesy Jeremy DanielNow You See Me Live

For marketing purposes, this 75-minute show has attached its cart to the Four Horsemen of the heist-film franchise Now You See Me, to which it is only glancingly related. The British charmer James More and the shaved-headed Canadian escapologist Darcy Oake, holdovers from previous Illusionists editions, are teamed here with the bespectacled English conjuror Matthew Pomeroy, who also plays host and shares tooth-breakingly stale jokes. (Introducing Oake: "The only thing he can't escape is his tax return!") South Africa's Gabriella Lester has a sequence involving computer animation on an LED wall—reminiscent of Trent's act in past versions—but she largely registers as a token woman in an overwhelmingly male-dominated profession; her most impressive feat may be passing through the glass ceiling without breaking it.

Gabriella Lester in Now You See Me Live
Photograph: Courtesy Johan PerssonNow You See Me Live

The evening has elements of skill, such as Pomeroy's proficient sleight-of-hand, and moments of suspense, as when Oake picks locks while holding his breath, suspended above the stage with his head in a box of water. And it has an oasis of beauty in a guest spot by South Korea's deft Eden Choi: a brief, dazzling set of card and ball illusions that Choi performed on Britain's Got Talent last year. Now You See Me Live is not on the level of the city's best magic shows, but it is also more affordable; because the large Al Hirschfeld Theatre is hard to fill, this production is likely to pop up on TKTS and other sources of discounted Broadway tickets. 

Eden Choi in Now You See Me Live
Photograph: Courtesy Jeremy DanielNow You See Me Live

I admit that I have been spoiled on artisanal close-up magic shows like Speakeasy Magick and Magic at the Clock Shop. For children and other spectators less wonder-jaded than I am, it may not matter that Now You See Me Live's material is familiar and the polish is uneven. But at the performance I saw, small flaws of execution detracted from the effects: mismatched shadows, an unconvincing blender, a visibly leaky cantaloupe. And although one late segment—featuring playing cards distributed to theatergoers as they file in—draws appreciative gasps, some of the other audience participation relies far too obviously on plants. Not all tricks are magic! But at least these ones are cheap.

Now You See Me Live. Al Hirschfeld Theatre (Broadway). Created by Simon Painter. Co-created by Adam Trent. Stage direction by Ash Jacks McCready. Illusion direction by Enzo Wayne. With Matthew Pomeroy, Darcy Oake, James More, Gabriella Lester, Eden Choi. Running time: 1hr 15mins. No intermission.

Follow Adam Feldman on X: @FeldmanAdam
Follow Adam Feldman on Bluesky: @FeldmanAdam
Follow Adam Feldman on Threads: @adfeldman
Watch Time Out’s theater podcast on YouTube: Sitting Ovations
Follow Time Out Theater on X: @TimeOutTheater
Keep up with the latest news and reviews on our Time Out Theater Facebook page

Popular on Time Out

    Latest news
      Advertising