Get us in your inbox

Don't Tell Mama sign
Photograph: Courtesy Don't Tell MamaDon't Tell Mama sign

You can still catch live music at these NYC piano bars

Listen to live singers and pianists as you drink and dine at these New York favorites.

Adam Feldman
Written by
Adam Feldman

New York City, one of the live music capitals of the world, has mostly been eerily silent since March, when a ban on indoor performances went into effect. But several beloved local cabaret venues have found a way to stay within the city's health guidelines while providing New Yorkers with the in-person music they crave—with live musicians playing for audiences that are safely seated outdoors.

Ticketed concerts remain prohibited, but these performances are technically incidental music: They provide background ambience at restaurants and bars. And for as long as the weather will permit it—or even beyond that, knowing New Yorkers—it can be a special experience.

The West Bank Cafe (407 W 42nd St), a classic theater-district dining spot, has moved the piano from its downstairs room to the front window. Instrumentalists perform there from Wednesdays through Sundays, and prominent vocalists, too: Great American Songbook eminence KT Sullivan on Fridays, jazz chick Gabrielle Stravelli on Saturdays and the witty cabaret duo of Michael Garin and Mardie Millit on Sundays.

"I've been around artists and musicians and creative people my whole life, and it's stunning how much people miss playing live," says West Bank Cafe owner Steve Olsen, who opened the restaurant in 1978. "The audience is the same way. People are starving for entertainment. They're rolling down their windows and applauding from their cars. It's very emotionally moving."

The longtime theater-district piano bar Don't Tell Mama (343 W 46th St) has set up an electric keyboard outside its door, and its singing bartenders and waiters wear masks as they tend to customers on the patio and the street every night of the week. "In one hand they may be serving a drink or a plate and in the other they have a cordless microphone," says the venue's booking manager, Sidney Myer. "They're creating the same atmosphere they would be making inside."

Gerry Dieffenbach | Photograph: Courtesy Don't Tell Mama

In a similar vein, the Upper East Side piano bar Brandy's (235 E 84th St) has been able to bring back almost all of its small staff for nightly entertainment. "The pianist is indoors and the singers are generally outdoors," explains John Bronson, who plays piano there on Saturday nights. "People really seem to enjoy it. The space has been filling up."

As indoor dining returns to New York in a limited capacity, live indoor music is coming back with it: Ellen's Stardust Diner reopened this week, complete with singing waitstaff, and Michael Garin is playing at Tribeca's Roxy Hotel on Wednesdays through Saturdays from 6pm–8pm. But customers who are not sure how they feel about dining indoors can enjoy the outdoor option. 

Here are the current schedules for music at the West Bank Cafe, Don't Tell Mama and Brandy's. And remember: If you want to tip the performers, as is customary, then by all means do. It's been a rough year.

West Bank Cafe:
Open Wednesday–Saturday 4pm–10pm, Sunday noon–8pm
Wednesday: Walter Blanding Quartet (7pm–9 pm)
Thursday: John Smalta Trio (7pm–9pm)
Friday: KT Sullivan (5pm–6:30 pm); Bill Hayes and the Jazz Bandits featuring John Samorian (7pm-9pm)
Saturday: Will Boulware (5pm–6:30 pm); Gabrielle Stravelli Trio (7pm–8:30pm)
Sunday: Michael Garin and Mardie Millit (6pm–8pm)

Don't Tell Mama:
Open nightly 4pm–midnight
Monday: Michael Isaacs (8pm)
Tuesday: Joe Regan (8pm)
Wednesday: rotating pianists (8pm)
Thursday: Nate Buccieri (8pm)
Friday: Gerry Dieffenbach (8pm)
Saturday: William TN Hall (8pm)
Sunday: Nate Buccieri (8pm)
With singing waitstaff Anna Anderson, Joshua Bennett, Elaine Brier, Paul Pilcz, Jon Satrom, Tommy J Dose, Brian Kalinowski, Tara Martinez, Joseph Redd, Alison Nusbaum and Laura Pavles 

Open nightly 5pm–11pm, music 5:30pm–10pm
Monday: Nate Buccieri with Jennifer Pace and David Foley Jr.
Tuesday: Michael Isaacs with Erica Lustig and Jon Satrom
Wednesday: Elliot Roth with Jennifer Pace and Justin Gregory Lopez
Thursday: Will TN Hall with Lauren Mufson and Sean Bernardi
Friday: Nate Buccieri with Liz Lark Brown and Justin Gregory Lopez
Saturday: John Bronston with Lauren Mufson and Bobby Belfry
Sunday: Michael Isaacs with Sean Bernardi and Liz Lark Brown

West Bank Cafe | Photograph: Courtesy West Bank Cafe

Most popular on Time Out

- Find out if you’re a real New Yorker with this interactive map
- 13 weird things New Yorkers have learned to accept
- The 20 rules of living in New York
- The 100 best movies of all time
- The coziest airbnbs you can rent near NYC this fall

Want to know what’s cool in the city before your friends do? Sign up to our newsletter for the latest and greatest from NYC and beyond.

Popular on Time Out

    More on Love Local

      Latest news