11 best lobster rolls in Boston

What it is: Head to this Seaport mainstay (they’ve been at it for 75 years) for lobster rolls, fried clams, steamers, chowder and other classic seafood shack dishes.

Why we love it: You'll find the classic hot and cold lobster rolls, but what really sets this place apart is its fried version. That's right, the kitchen fries pieces of fresh lobster and serves it on a bun. Purists may cringe at the thought, but more for you? The Crobster Roll is also a fan‑favorite mash‑up with tons of fresh meat from both crabs and lobsters. Check out the heated outdoor patio when it’s open for the season.

Address: 300 Northern Ave, Boston, MA 02210

Opening hours: Mon.-Sat. 11am-8pm; Sun. 11am-7pm

What it is: This no-frills seafood shack ships 50,000 pounds of lobster to restaurants and wholesale distributors around the country each day, so you know its product is fresh and delicious.

Why we love it: Served on a buttery roll and overflowing with meat, its lobster roll has just the right ratio of mayo and seasoning (or you can order it with just butter – it’s your call). You can also head to the counter and order up some fresh seafood and lobsters to go to cook at home.

Address: 440 Atlantic Ave, Boston, MA 02110

Opening hours: Sun.-Thurs. 10am-4pm; Fri. and Sat. 10am-5pm

What it is: If you’re going to splurge on one of these sandwiches, why not go straight to the source? Luke’s Lobster is a family-owned seafood business that was founded by third-generation lobsterman, Luke Holden, and sustainably sources these crustaceans from the waters of Maine.

Why we love it: There are two storefronts throughout the city (and one in Fenway on the 1st base concourse and on Jersey Street), each serving four- or six-ounces of fresh lobster meat stuffed into a toasted buttered bun with a swipe of mayo, a drizzle of lemon butter, and a sprinkle of Luke’s Secret Seasoning. The Lobster Roll Flight is a great sampler of three half-rolls: lemon butter, spicy honey butter, and truffle butter w/ chips and a soft drink.

Address: 75 Exeter St, Boston, MA 02116 and 290 Washington St., Boston, MA 02108

Opening hours: Check website for hours.

What it is: This East Boston restaurant is a landmark waterfront destination, with a globally-inspired menu that incorporates all of the fresh New England flavors. You can also get to it by a boat shuttle, maximizing your seaside time.

Why we love it: Reelhouse serves their lobster rolls both hot or cold, topped with drawn butter and mixed greens all wrapped up in a toasted bun. The elevated dining experience isn’t complete until you’ve enjoyed a specialty cocktail and have taken a photo of the breathtaking view. 

Address: 6 New St., Boston, MA 02128

Opening hours: Check website for hours.

What it is: Pauli's, a North End staple, is renowned for its generous sandwiches. Whether you're up for a challenge or simply looking for a satisfying meal, Pauli's lobster rolls are sure to hit the spot.

Why we love it: This is dedication to the art of lobster rolls. The USS Lobstitution is a massive sandwich that boasts a whopping 28 ounces of knuckle and claw meat. For those who prefer a more moderate portion size, Pauli's also serves a 7-ounce grilled New England style hot dog roll and a 14-ounce grilled sub served with twist of lemon and mayo.

Address: 65 Salem St, Boston, MA 02113

Opening hours: Mon.- Fri. 8am-9pm; Sat. 10am-9pm; Sun. 10am-5pm

What it is: North End favorite Neptune Oyster is exemplary in its East Coast seafood preparations. And the long lines at this super tiny location are evidence.

Why we love it: Neptune’s lobster roll is one of the most celebrated, available either hot with butter, or cold with mayo, both served on a toasted brioche roll. Given that this tiny eatery is located in one of the busiest neighborhoods in town, you can expect a wait out the door for a marble-topped table or a seat at the bar.

Address: 63 Salem St # 1, Boston, MA 02113

Opening hours: Daily 11am-9:30pm (10:30pm on weekends)

What it is: For locals, it's a tradition, and for visitors, it's a special treat. Sullivan's Castle Island has been serving customers since 1951, and has since become synonymous with the perfect summer take-out experience.

Why we love it: While the iconic snack shack offers all the classic dishes, the lobster roll is a must-try. Customers can enjoy their food right by the water, either from the picnic tables outside or the nearby grassy area. If you're feeling full after your meal, it's not uncommon to take a walk around the Castle Island loop and return to Sully’s for a second helping.

Address: 2080 William J Day Blvd, South Boston, MA 02127

Opening hours: Daily 10am-7pm seasonally

What it is: Since it opened its Fenway location, Portland-based Eventide has been luring in gourmands to sample its unique take on the classic sandwich and classic New England fare.

Why we love it: This James Beard Award-winning restaurant is famous for its brown butter lobster roll. This singular treat features a bao-like bun, which soaks up all of the delicious dressing while perfectly complimenting the sweet Maine lobster meat.

Address: 1321 Boylston St. Boston, MA 02215

Opening hours: Check website for hours.

What it is: Simple and straightforward, Lobstah on a Roll specializes in just that (although the Back Bay spot does offer other seafood specials, soup, starters and even wings).

Why we love it: Whether you choose it with hot butter or mayo or naked, the four ounces of lobster meat in the Bostonian is a tasty way to pack a grilled split-top New England style bun (the Patriot is a little smaller, clocking in at three ounces of meat). If you want a little twist, try lobstah grilled cheese made with melted cheddar cheese and succulent New England lobster meat sandwiched between sourdough bread.

Address: 254 Newbury St, Boston, MA 02116

Opening hours: Daily 11:30am-9:30pm

What it is: The Banks Fish House was launched as an homage to the sea and its captains by the team behind local institutions Bistro du Midi and Grill 23.

Why we love it: This establishment offers its roll hot or cold on a brown butter bun. Topped with sea salt and chives, and paired with Old Bay potato chips, this version tastes like summer on a plate.

Address: 406 Stuart St., Boston, Massachusetts 02116

Opening hours: Check website for hours.

Boston’s best seafood restaurants serve fresh, local fish in a variety of preparations, from freshly shucked oysters and creamy clam chowder to delicate crudo. Some restaurants focus on traditional New England recipes, while others prepare their seafood with Italian or Mediterranean influences.