1 Love It
Save it

The best margaritas in Chicago

The best margaritas have plenty of fresh lime juice and no shortage of tequila, plus a few surprises

Photograph: Jaclyn Rivas

Whether it's National Margarita Day (that's February 22, so clear your calendar), Cinco de Mayo or any day a tequila and lime craving strikes, you can consult our list to find the best margaritas in town. Everything from textbook classics to a high-end version with gold flakes made the cut, and you can drink them at tiny Mexican restaurants, cocktail bars and even at a beer bar.

RECOMMENDED: Our guide to cocktails in Chicago

Best margaritas in Chicago

1

Pepino Margarita at Del Toro

The margarita starts simple—silver tequila, lime, Cointreau—and then the bartender doctors it up with cucumber, jalapeno, simple syrup and a chile pequin rim. The cucumber makes it taste light and fresh, while the chile-lime salted rim adds heat to every sip. $8. —Amy Cavanaugh

Read more
Lower West Side
2

House Rosemary Margarita at Antique Taco

It makes sense that the cutest taco joint in town also has the cutest margarita. At Antique Taco, the simple margarita—tequila, plus fresh lime and orange juices—gets a hint of sweetness and herbal notes from rosemary simple syrup. It’s garnished with a sprig of rosemary and available both by the glass and the quart—considering the heat some of the tacos carry, you’ll want to go big. $8, glass $30, quart.AC

Read more
Wicker Park
3

Classic Margarita at Big Star

Big Star makes two margaritas: the classic, with Lunazul Blanco, lime and orange curacao, and the Big Star, which adds in mezcal. While we’re usually all over mezcal margaritas, here it’s a bit too strong. Stick with the simple but well-crafted classic, which is also available in a pitcher for $36, a requirement if you’re whiling away an afternoon over a plate of tacos. $9. —AC

Read more
Wicker Park
Advertising
4

Where There is Smoke at Masa Azul

The Mexican restaurant knows its tequila, and there are several margaritas on the cocktail list. Where There is Smoke 's name says it all: The smoky mezcal hits you up front and it’s followed by fire from the serrano chile. The orange liqueur and lime juice mellow both flavors out, resulting in a balanced margarita. $10. —AC

Read more
Logan Square
5

De Noche Rita at De Noche Mexicana

Margaritas at De Noche Mexicana are no joke, whether you want a twist on the old classic with the De Noche Rita ($9) or prefer to kick things up a notch with the smooth but serious Margarita Suprema ($14)—a mix of Don Julio reposado tequila and Grand Marnier, plus anejo rum and citrus mix. That said, a $32 pitcher of the trusted house ’rita—El Charro blanco tequila, orange liqueur, orange liqueur and de noche citrus mix—goes down easy. Add a taste of blackberry, mango, passion fruit or guava for $3. —Laura Rote

Book now Read more
Logan Square
6

Morgan Street Margarita at Maria’s Packaged Goods & Community Bar

Proof that Maria’s is the most underrated cocktail joint in town: this margarita, which is made with Monte Alban Mezcal Joven, 1800 Reposado Tequila 100, lime juice and spicy simple syrup. There’s only a bit of heat, but combined with the smoky mezcal, it’s so good you’ll want to order a second immediately after you finish your first. $10. —AC

Read more
Bridgeport
Advertising
7

The Tin Machine at Publican Anker

Beer may be the focus at Publican Anker, but there's one cocktail on the list that we keep going back to—the Tin Machine. This tequila drink is filled with Lunazul for its boozy kick and Licor 43 to give it a citrusy punch. Sweetened and spiced with house-made serrano honey and topped with fresh pineapple juice, it's a refreshing twist on a margarita (and one that you could probably chase with a beer). $10. —Elizabeth Atkinson

Read more
Wicker Park
8

Splurge Margarita at Frontera Grill

While the gold flakes may remind you of Goldschlager shots in college, drinking this margarita, served neat in a filled-to-the-brim martini glass, will end a lot better than those frat ragers. That’s because this drink is made with incredibly high-end ingredients (hence, the incredibly high-end price): Don Julio 1942, Grand Marnier, the French aperitif Pineau des Charentes and those aforementioned gold flakes. If you like cognac (the tequila is aged in Cognac barrels and Pineau des Charantes is infused with the stuff), you’ll like the mellow Sweet Tart flavor of this drink. If you don’t…uh, stick with Goldschlager? $30.Laura Baginski

Read more
River North
9

Hot Mez at La Mez Agave Lounge

At La Mez Agave Lounge, the margarita comes with mescal, herbal liqueur, Grand Marnier, lime and lightly sweetened with agave. It makes for a great after work drink, and you can sometimes find the cocktail being offered at half price, accompanied by small plates of food. $13. —EA

Read more
River North
Advertising
10

Horchata Margarita at Best Intentions

Best Intentions has a fantastic patio, and while you could easily cool down with the delicious Wondermint Malted, you might be looking for something a little lighter. Try the Horchata Margarita, a little sweet but not cloying. Everything else stays the same, with a pop of tequila, this margarita aims to please. $8. —EA

Read more
Logan Square
11

Margarita Tradicional at Mercadito

When it comes to margaritas, keeping it simple is often the best course of action. This River North hotspot offers a variety of margaritas, most of which are mixed with unexpected ingredients like cumin salt and almonds, but the best of the bunch is a straightforward adherent to the form: El Jimador Blanco tequila, agave nectar, Grand Marnier and fresh lime juice. Caution: Do not pay an extra $3 to “add smoke” to this margarita, unless you like a mouthful of campfire. $12.50 —LB

Book now Read more
River North
12

Pineapple Serrano at Takito Kitchen

Between the tequila, Cointreau, pineapple and spicy Serrano, there’s a lot of flavor here, but it all melds together beautifully. And while we’re not entirely sure what the bartenders are doing to make the chile-citrus-salt-sugar rim so good, we also don’t really care. $11. —AC

Book now Read more
Ukrainian Village
Advertising

Find more of our top Mexican picks by dish

Chicago's most authentic and original Mexican food

We don't ever need an excuse to gorge ourselves on the city’s stellar Mexican offerings. (We’d happily scale a mountain of snow for 2am tamales!) And whether we're bundled up in our parkas or shedding our winter layers for some warmer weather, we're always in the mood for tacos, enchiladas and hard-hitting, ice-cold margaritas. We decided to check out the best—and most authentic—Mexican food in Chicago, dish by delicious dish.

Read more
By: Elizabeth Atkinson

Comments

3 comments
Tomislav L
Tomislav L

What about el Chingon at Tanta!?

michetique
michetique tastemaker

I rather enjoyed the pitcher of classic marg I had at Cesca's in Andersonville.  Doesn't seem like Cesca's is on TO at all.  That should be rectified.

Elena J
Elena J

You missed the pineapple jalapeno Margarita at the Palmer house!