Get us in your inbox

Search
The dining room at Gimlet restaurant
Photograph: Earl Carter

Time Out Food & Drink Awards 2023: Best Fine Dining Restaurant

Here is the winner of Best Fine Dining Restaurant in the Time Out Melbourne Food & Drink Awards 2023

Written by
Time Out editors
Advertising

Melbourne’s hospo industry might be trudging through one of its tougher economic eras as of late, but there’s no denying it: our passion and respect for elevated dining is still very much alive.

After all, we’re one of the most happening food cities in the world – and while swanky wine bars and more casual watering holes might be rising in popularity, both classic and new fine diners continue to shine brightly in their own right. Though we may not dine there on the daily, we bask in their glow with gratitude. 

From glitzy lobster feasts with caviar table service to farm-to-table degustations that have stood the test of time, there’s no doubt that what our fancier establishments offer is world-class in its wow factor. And when the occasion allows (even if it’s just for some much-needed TLC or a romantic date night escape to another world), we’ll gladly whip out our wallets for the good stuff.

It’s no easy feat to choose from such vastly different and iconic jewels in our city, but the brief was clear: to find those fine diners that charm us every damn time. It’s not just about the food; it’s about the finer subtleties of the experience: the sommelier’s manner, the ambience, the connection, that special something that’s hard to define without coming off as pretentious. But you know what we mean; when it’s there, you can just feel it.

This year, we honed in on the restaurants that bedazzled us with their imagination and attention to detail. We appreciated the simple pleasures: artfully presented premium produce that sings on the plate, comfort over high fashion and classic old-school hospitality with a smile. From the much-loved Gimlet at Cavendish House (last year’s People's Choice Award winner for Favourite Restaurant) to the new and highly ambitious Reine and La Rue that’s living up to its debut buzz, we’re proud of our selection and suggest you earmark this guide for the next time a swish dinner out is on the cards. You’ll leave feeling like royalty, that much is certain.

Click here to return to the main awards page.

And the winner is...

  • 5 out of 5 stars
  • Restaurants
  • Bars
  • Melbourne
  • price 3 of 4

To question Gimlet’s beauty is like pondering out loud whether the sky is blue. One foot through the door into the Trader House team’s almighty fine diner and you’re swept into an era of astonishingly impressive 1920s glamour. The handsome, plush curved booths invite you to settle in and share a bottle of Champers with a friend, uniformed staff skate around the floor with ease, and warm light dances off the grand chandeliers overhead. It’s undeniably fabulous, but also cosy at the same time – less ostentatious ‘razzle-dazzle’ and more hearth-y and heartwarming somehow, even in all its magnificence.

 

We also love these other nominees...

  • 5 out of 5 stars
  • Restaurants
  • Beaconsfield
  • price 3 of 4

This is very much going to sound like a first-world problem, but sometimes you’re simply not in the mood for the laborious mental demands of high-brow degustation dining. Unlike hoeing into a bowl of spag bol at your mum’s house or sharing a pizza with friends, taking the time to critically ponder the creative life’s work of a chef can feel tense and serious. This is why after a 45-minute drive from Melbourne to Beaconsfield, I’m grateful to discover the famous O.My to be a surprisingly relaxing affair. It’s hushed with natural light, as comfortable as a reading room in a library, and boasts no ostentatious distractions or highfalutin tricks up its sleeve. Serenity, at last.

 

  • 5 out of 5 stars
  • Restaurants
  • Melbourne

Anyone with even the slightest interest in Melbourne’s food and hospitality scene has been talking about Reine and La Rue as of late. The highly ambitious project from Nomad Group has transformed Melbourne’s hallowed old Stock Exchange building into a European-inspired restaurant as ritzy as it is regal, with a speakeasy bar (the Rue part) accessible through an adjoining courtyard. It’s the first time the space has been open to the public in more than 20 years and the obsession is real. But big talk doesn’t always lead to a big walk, and so I was determined to discover if the new dining venture is as good as others say. Spoiler alert: it’s even better.

 

Advertising
  • 5 out of 5 stars
  • Restaurants
  • Armadale

From the moment you book the full seasonal tasting experience on Amaru’s website, you know you’re in for an odyssey. It’s the restaurant’s most extravagant offering, after all – with five snacks, seven courses and petit fours, plus optional drink pairings. Skipping brekky isn’t a bad idea, but that’s not to say the food at Amaru will be dense or cumbersome – the progression of light to heavier dishes is carefully designed, a thoughtful pacing that allows you to take as long as you please in comfort.

 

  • 5 out of 5 stars
  • Restaurants
  • Japanese
  • Melbourne

While our city is filled with a labyrinth of outstanding and historic establishments, few really deserve the coveted title of being a Melbourne culinary institution – an overused and often meaningless phrase. However, after experiencing a meal in the tranquil yet dynamic dining room at Kenzan, the Collins Street restaurant that has been serving traditional Japanese fare since 1981, you leave with the feeling that there aren’t many ways more apt to describe the place. 

 

Recommended
    You may also like
    You may also like
    Advertising