Don’t let the crowds deter you—the line moves quickly at this iconic, standing-room-only pizza joint (where it's not uncommon to have a celebrity sighting). A plain Neapolitan-style slice will only run you $3.21, but take it from us and throw another buck toward the Spicy Spring square slice, a thick and doughy Sicilian-style crust topped with Fra Diavolo sauce, spicy pepperoni and gooey mozzarella ($4.52).
Most New Yorkers would agree that Gotham is best known for two things: stellar cheap pizza and exorbitant rent. The latter fueling our endless quest for the best cheap eats in NYC. And although we’ll happily indulge in a late-night dollar slice at one of several 24-hour pizza spots or go in on pizza delivery just to save a buck or two, sometimes we crave a touch of ambiance that only an authentic eat-in New York pizzeria can provide. From $3 slices to $12 calzones, these za joints are serving up some of our favorite cheap New York pizzas.
RECOMMENDED: Full guide to the best restaurants in NYC