The best mince pies in London, ranked
£1.35 for six
The best of the supermarket pies, Aldi’s cognac-laced number has an over-wet filling, but it’s satisfyingly boozy, with a citrusy, subtly spicy mincemeat. The pastry has a mass-produced softness, but maintains rigidity under pressure (*snort*).
Buy them from Aldi online or in-store.
St John’s pies are old-school and ever-so grown up (like St John itself, basically): think shortbread-short and fatty pastry, with a nicely dense, heavily spiced filling that’s got a fine boozy thwack to it. Chin chin!
Buy them from the St John Bakery, 72 Druid St, SE1 2HQ. Open Saturday 9am-4pm.
Pretty they ain’t, but these deep-filled numbers are the most savoury-tasting pie on the list. That’s a compliment: the super-short casings are crumbly with fat, and the mincemeat is almost Chrimbo pud in texture. One for the adults.
Buy them from Bread Ahead, 249 Pavilion Rd, London SW1X 0BP.
£2 each/£7.50 for four
This ace Dulwich/Peckham bakery’s superlative pie is as much an Eccles cake as a trad mincey, with a dense, rum-soaked currant filling and super thin pastry that’s also dead robust. Classic stuff.
Buy them at Brick House East Dulwich, 1 Zenoria St, SE22 8HP ; or Brick House Peckham Rye, Unit 5, 12-16 Blenheim Grove, SE15 4QL.
They didn't make the four-strong hitlist, but the following pies all had their charms:
Aldi, ‘Exquisite’ frangipane-topped mince pies (£2.99 for six)
Butterscotch, jumbo mince pies (£15 for six; pictured)
Greggs, sweet mince pies (£1.75 for six)
Konditor & Cook, standard mince pies (£12 for six)
Ottolenghi, standard mince pies (£7.80 for three)
Pearl & Groove, gluten-free mince pie (£3.50 each)
Pret, standard mince pie (£1.45 each)
Waitrose, ‘Essential’ shortcrust mince pies (£1.80 for six)
London's restaurants open on Xmas day
Snap up exclusive discounts in London
Time Out's handpicked deals — hurry, they won't be around for long...