The best comfort food dishes in NYC

New York's best comfort food dishes include fried chicken, macaroni and cheese and slurp-ready soup dumplings
Blueberry pancakes at Clinton St Baking
Photograph: Courtesy Michael Harlan Turkell
By Christina Izzo and Alyson Penn |
Advertising

When it’s cold, dark and all you want is a little taste of home, there’s nothing more belly-warming than the best comfort food dishes in NYC. They’re dishes like Mom used to make, but professionally done (sorry, Ma)—we’re talking about some of the city’s best chocolate chip cookies, best soup dumplings and the best fried chicken in NYC. Take a bite out of the tastiest comfort food dishes in New York City.

RECOMMENDED: Full guide to the best restaurants in NYC

Best comfort food dishes in NYC

1
Battle of the Burger 2014
Restaurants, Hamburgers

Burger at J.G. Melon’s

icon-location-pin Lenox Hill

The cheeseburger at this kitschy Upper East Side haunt is a bite of a bygone era, simple griddled on a flattop and medium-rare juicy. The thick, eight-ounce burger arrives open-faced, peeking beneath a layer of melted American cheese on a pillow-soft, lightly toasted bun, with sliced tomato, crisp lettuce, red onion and dill-pickle chips on the side. Don’t bypass the bacon—the deep-fried tangle adds delicious textural contrast to the coarsely packed patty.

2
Breads Bakery
Photograph: Courtesy Brian Kennedy
Restaurants, Bakeries

Chocolate babka at Breads Bakery

icon-location-pin Union Square

If you get one of warm, chocolate-webbed loaves fresh out of the oven at this Union Square bakery, you’re in for sweet-tooth nirvana. The bread is doughy yet flaky, and the chocolate is mixed with Nutella to create a rich, yet not-too-sweet filling. The hype is real, people. 

Advertising
3
Matzo Ball Soup at Peck's Specialty Foods
Photograph: Courtesy Peck's Specialty Foods
Restaurants, Bakeries

Matzo-ball soup at Peck’s

icon-location-pin Clinton Hill

Theo Peck’s rich, restorative matzo-ball soup is as old-school as his deli roots (Peck is the great-grandson of the cofounder of famed kosher-dairy restaurant Ratner’s), swimming with slips of confit rotisserie chicken, carrot and celery batons, and one giant sinker, the dill-flecked midpoint between dense and tender.

4
Maman
Photograph: Laura Gallant
Restaurants, Cafés

Chocolate-chip cookie at Maman

icon-location-pin Little Italy

Combining the best of American baking and French technique, the chocolate-studded stunner at Armand Arnal’s Soho café could tempt even the most ardent Levain loyalist. The Michelin-starred chef (France’s La Chassagnette) uses imported chocolate for its melty core, sprinkled with sea salt and crammed with macadamias, almonds and walnuts, with oven-kissed edges so buttery, they rival toffee. $3.75

Advertising
5
Photograph: Courtesy Yelp/ The Smith
Restaurants, American

Mac and cheese at The Smith

icon-location-pin Midtown East

It wouldn't be a list of comfort food without an appearance from this classic and this midtown American brasserie is serving some of the best mac and cheese in town. There is never a bad time to get an order of this golden, bubbly pasta in a creamy cheese sauce, arriving in a cast-iron dish straight from the oven. 

6
Blueberry pancakes at Clinton St Baking
Photograph: Courtesy Michael Harlan Turkell
Restaurants, American

Blueberry pancakes at Clinton St. Baking Company

icon-location-pin Lower East Side

Head over early (yes, there will be a line) to this Lower East Side breakfast favorite to taste the golden flapjacks that are on nearly every NYC must-eat list. Stacked in a set of three, the pancakes are fluffy, buttery and topped with wild Maine blueberry compote (or banana walnut or chocolate chunk—your choice!) with a side of warm maple butter.

Advertising
7
The Halal Guys
Photograph: Courtesy The Halal Guys
Restaurants

Lamb plate at The Halal Guys

icon-location-pin Midtown West

The Halal Guys are the kings of street meat. For a mere $7, the Midtown food-cart vendors stuff an aluminum foil dish with warm rice, lettuce, vegetables, meat (chicken, lamb or beef) and top it off with your choice of sauces (red or white) and some pita bread. Comfort is knowing that you’re going to get the same thing every time, and sometimes that’s all you need. 

8
Root & Bone
Photograph: Paul Wagtouicz
Restaurants, Soul and southern American

Fried chicken at Root & Bone

icon-location-pin East Village

Top Chef alums Jeff McInnis and Janine Booth brine Pennsylvania Dutch country chicken in sweet tea spiked with paprika and cayenne for 24 hours, giving it a distinct sweetness amplified by the dusting of dehydrated lemon powder the bird gets when it’s pulled golden and crunchy from the pressure cooker. A drizzle of Tabasco honey happily keeps that salty-sweet tug-of-war going.

Advertising
9
MU RAMEN mu ramen
Photograph: Paul Wagtouicz
Restaurants, Japanese

Mu Ramen at Mu Ramen

icon-location-pin Long Island City

Is there anything more fortifying in the cold than a soul-warming bowl of noodles and broth? At husband-and-wife team Joshua and Heidy Smookler’s Long Island City ramen-ya, the namesake ramen is based with a beefy 20-hour broth of oxtail and bone marrow—heartier than your average chicken-stock soup—bobbing with hunks of brisket, fermented bamboo shoots, cabbage and half-sour pickle shreds.

10
East Pole fish pie
Photograph: Melissa Sinclair
Restaurants, American

Fish-and-fennel potpie at the East Pole

icon-location-pin Lenox Hill

Britain’s humble fish pie gets a high-minded overhaul at this uptown Anglo canteen. Chef Joseph Capozzi binds flaky pollock and generous hunks of lobster claw with a tarragon-flecked fennel puree, adding a jolt of brightness, all tucked beneath a thick, bubbly head of puff pastry that’s practically begging to be pierced with a spoon.

Show more

Have a hankering for nachos?

Advertising