The coolest secret places in NYC

We spill the beans on secret places in NYC from restaurants and bars to parties—but keep this info on the down-low
Photograph: Paul Wagtouicz Le Boudoir
Advertising

Our New York attractions are known across the globe, but what about the lesser-known, secret places in NYC? Thanks to us, you don’t have to do much digging. We’re sharing a classified list of hidden spots that throw the coolest secret parties, host the most outlandish dinners and more hush-hust events and speakeasies. Just one thig: Let’s try to keep this information between us, ya dig?

Coolest secret things to do in NYC

1
Secret Loft
Photograph: Tak Wind Fotografi

Secret Loft

So illegal warehouse raves aren’t your thing, and the spontaneity of a TBA address isn’t as appealing as the comfort of knowing where you’re going? We hear you—and so does Secret Loft, a venue that can host a bash—it once had a cat costume soiree, people!—and still has that roving, under-the-radar Bushwick vibe. 

How to get in: Check out Secret Loft’s Facebook page for event information, then show up at the McKibbin Street Lofts at showtime to look for other revelers. 255 McKibbin St, Brooklyn (facebook.com/secretloft)

Photograph: Tak Wind Fotografi

2
Le Boudoir
Bars, Cocktail bars

Le Boudoir

icon-location-pin Brooklyn Heights

The cellar-speakeasy hidden in the Brooklyn Heights French bistro Chez Moi is a cocktail bar fit for a queen. Modeled after Marie Antoinette’s opulent private chambers, Le Boudoir has its historically accurate design down to a T, with plush red-velvet–tufted banquettes, gilded frames, wooden paneling and a ceiling reproduction of the 17th-century parquet de Versailles flooring pattern. After ducking into the secret passage, sip appropriately named cocktails like the absinthe-based Dauphin and the 1793, featuring rye infused with sunflower seeds, served in antique-looking metal goblets, and lounge in a dimly lit grotto while discussing French politics…or something like that.

How to get in: Head through a bookcase door on the left side of Chez Moi, and step down a set of stairs. 135 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn (347-227-8337, boudoirbk.com)

Advertising
3
538 Johnson
Photograph: Alfredo "sheep" Hernandez

538 Johnson

Screw all that “DIY is dead” talk. When it comes to off-the-radar concerts and nontraditional venues, Brooklyn is still where it’s at. Take the Bushwick loft 538 Johnson, a true house party (people really live there) where hardcore, punk and ripping rock acts (Dawn of Humans and the Men have both performed) reign, show publicity isn’t a thing, and sweat pours. Prepare for lots of moshing kids.

How to get in: Ask a crust punk. No, really, word-of-mouth is best. But 538 Johnson does have a Facebook page and occasionally updates on shows. 538 Johnson Ave, Brooklyn

Photograph: Alfredo "sheep" Hernandez

4
Karasu
Photograph: Paul Wagtouicz
Restaurants, Japanese

Karasu

icon-location-pin Fort Greene

Tucked behind an unmarked door at the back of Fort Greene’s beloved eatery Walter’s, the open-as-of-May Japanese izakaya, Karasu, is the newest speakeasy on the block. The elegant gastropub has a small but buzzed-about menu (spicy sesame duck wings, to start), but what packs ’em in are the drinks: a top-notch variety of sake, shochu and Japanese whiskey.

How to get in: Head to the back of Walter’s and through the unmarked door. Reservations are accepted on Karasu’s website. 166 DeKalb Ave, Brooklyn (347-223-4811, karasubk.com)

Photograph: Paul Wagtouicz

Advertising
5
Sublimate
Photograph: Luis Nieto Dickens
Clubs

Sublimate

icon-calendar

Since its inception in 2012, the loft-hopping after-hours affair Sublimate has gone from a sporadically booked treat to a hot monthly party that brings in DJ heavy hitters hailing from Ibiza to Chicago. Come rested: The nights, held in secret locations throughout town, can stretch to the 12-hour mark (the lack of megaclub douches and cheap-ass drinks should keep you perky and in a swell mood) and boast an awesome sound system courtesy of resident spinner Matt Sagotsky, whose aim is to create a diverse, come-one-come-all atmosphere.

How to get in: Sign up for Sublimate’s mailing list, R.S.V.P. for location details, or purchase tickets on Resident Advisor. sublimate.org.

Photograph: Luis Nieto Dickens

6
Photograph: Courtesy Chemistry NYC

Chemistry

Take a peek at what goes on behind NYC’s closed doors during Chemistry, an erotic roaming party intended for uninhibited sexual exploration. With themes like “Spanksgiving” and “Garden of Hedon,” the Brooklyncentric rendezvous start off as social gatherings, with live jazz and drinks, and then transition to the down and dirty. But before you get, ahem, excited, this isn’t a free-for-all: Chemistry partygoers are a curated group of members chosen through a two-part application process.

How to get in: Apply online by answering a questionnaire and submitting a G-rated photo. Couples and single women only; single men are usually not allowed unless they and a FWB (friend with benefits) apply as a couple. If accepted, you’ll receive a follow-up email with details regarding upcoming events. chemistry-nyc.comPhotograph: Courtesy Chemistry NYC

Advertising
7
dinnertable
Photograph: Courtesy of dinnertable
Restaurants, American

Dinnertable

icon-location-pin East Village

This reverse speakeasy—that is, a restaurant hiding in the back of a drinkery, in this case the Garret East—might sound familiar. (Its sister bar, the Garret, sits above a West Village Five Guys.) With space for only 20 diners, Dinnertable is decorated with wall-mounted planters, oddball prayer candles plastered with celeb faces, and photos of iconic Hollywood dinners. The food is made for sharing, but take one look at the lasagna bolognese, and you might not want to.

How to get in: Behind the curtain at the back of the Garret East, ring a doorbell that reads PRESS FOR FOOD. Dinnertable accepts some reservations on its website, but the majority of seating is set aside for walk-ins. 206 Ave A (dinnertable.nyc)

Photograph: Courtesy Dinnertable

8
Garfunkel's
Photograph: Liz Clayman
Bars, Cocktail bars

Garfunkel's

icon-location-pin Lower East Side

Even though you have to enter through a backroom vault with a secret code, we promise it’s all completely legal—quite unlike the embezzling exploits of 1920s bankers Max Garfunkel and Marcus Tauster, whose former office building is the exact location of Garfunkel’s, which sits above burger joint the Burgary. (Peep newspaper clippings from the duo’s felonious heyday amid the framed vintage photos.) The aesthetic here is old-school glam: Purple tones, velvet couches, tufted club chairs and a wall-engulfing bookcase with novels and knickknacks.

How to get in: Book a reservation online, and you’ll receive a code for the vault that’s located at the back of the Burgary. Walk-ins are accepted if space allows. 67 Clinton St (212-529-6999, garfunkelsnyc.com)

Photograph: Liz Clayman

Advertising
9
Blkmarket Membership 6 Year Anniversary Party
Photograph: Jena Cumbo

Blkmarket Membership

For the past 10 years, the DJs of Blkmarket Membership have been hosting parties in Brooklyn warehouses, on rooftops and in lofts and have become a go-to for late-night techno- and house-heads. Expect big names like Ben Klock and Michael Mayer.

How to get in: Sign up through residentadvisor.net. Only those they wish to come will be contacted back with the location.

Photograph: Jena Cumbo

10
<p>Courtesy Apotheke</p>
Bars, Lounges

Apothéke

icon-location-pin Chinatown

This unmarked boîte is the sort of contrived hideout that might be cooked up by an overgrown kid with a chemistry set. The bar is littered with old vials, the cocktails are referred to as “prescriptions,” and the bartenders-cum-mad-scientists are in rare form—note the cinnamon-flambéed Himalayan salt that rims a margarita. Does all this hocus-pocus translate to better drinks? Well, the Tainted Love (a sweet stress reliever made of beet juice and gin) as well as the Sitting Buddha (a vodka and lemongrass elixir made with fresh pineapple, pressed ginger root, lime juice and agave) certainly cured our sobriety. 

How to get in: Just next to Nom Wah Tea Parlor, step through the wooden door with a sign that reads "Chemist" overhead. 9 Doyers St #1 (212-406-0400, apothekenyc.com).

Advertising
11
The 18th Room
Photograph: Courtesy Noah Fecks
Bars, Cocktail bars

The 18th Room

icon-location-pin Chelsea

The team behind Bathtub Gin opens another upscale, Prohibition-style speakeasy in Chelsea cheekily named for the amendment that ushered in the booze ban. Sip intricate quaffs like the quail-egg–topped Sensi Crickete (rum, stout, cacao), or slink into a velvet banquette inside the moody, Art Deco lounge. 

How to get in: Step through a faux coffee shop to sit at the marble-top bar. 134 9th Ave (646-559-1671). 

12
Featherweight
Photograph: Courtesy Featherweight

Featherweight

Need proof that the NYC speakeasy is alive and well—and still, you know, kinda cool? Check out Featherweight, the East Williamsburg cocktail den from the mixology minds of Weather Up, which is hidden above the restaurant Sweet Science. Drawing inspiration from a former boxing gym that occupied the second-floor space, it’s an ace spot for sipping drinks with fancy-sounding ingredients (the Patagonia Punch has pisco, rum, Génépy des Alpes and orgeat) in an intimate—but not pretentious—rustic Polynesian-like setting. Lightweight drinkers need not apply.

How to get in: There are two ways to enter: through a door at the back of Sweet Science and on a landing outside. (If you opt for the latter, look for the huge painted mural of a boxer. The door below it with the feather on it is your ticket in.) 135 Graham Ave, Brooklyn (featherweightbk.com)

Photograph: Courtesy Featherweight

Advertising
13
Bohemian
Photograph: Zandy Mangold

Bohemian

The bad news: This covert Japanese-influenced restaurant, which sits beyond a butcher shop on Great Jones Street, has no published phone number. And the only surefire way to reserve a spot at this 25-seater is to get its digits from a previous diner. (You can also try your luck by emailing ny-info@playearth.jp with the subject line “Visit Enquiry” for a chance to be selected for a reservation.) The good news: Getting into the super-exclusive space, which was once home to Jean-Michel Basquiat, will give you bragging rights for months. For being so VIP, Bohemian’s decor is quite simple—minimalist, with a Zen garden, lounge chairs and plenty of wall art—and its menu is down-to-earth (but delish!), with wagyu beef sliders and mac and cheese.

How to get in: Bohemian shares a storefront with Japan Premium Beef; find the long hallway to the left of the butcher shop, and ring the buzzer at the end of the hall to enter Bohemian. 57 Great Jones St (playearth.jp)

Photograph: Zandy Mangold

Looking for more things to do in NYC?

Advertising