Worldwide icon-chevron-right North America icon-chevron-right United States icon-chevron-right New York State icon-chevron-right New York icon-chevron-right The best Brooklyn pizza in NYC

Heads up! We’re working hard to be accurate – but these are unusual times, so please always check before heading out.

LUCALI basil pizza
Photograph: Paul Wagtouicz Lucali

The best Brooklyn pizza in NYC

From thin-and-crackly Neapolitan to mozzarella-oozing thick crust, this is the best Brooklyn pizza in NYC

By Christina Izzo and Time Out contributors
Advertising

When people talk about the best New York pizza, they’re really talking about one borough: Brooklyn, home to both legendary dough punchers like Dom DeMarco and new-wave trailblazers like the Roberta’s crew. These are more than your cheap-pizza dollar slices–this is some of the best pizza in America, made with time-honored techniques, hyperfresh ingredients and plenty of attitude. This exemplary crop of restaurants in NYC is serving the best Brooklyn pizza in town.

RECOMMENDED: See more of the best pizza in NYC

Best Brooklyn pizza in NYC

Regular pie at Di Fara Pizza
Photograph: Caroline Voagen Nelson

1. Di Fara Pizza

Restaurants Pizza Midwood

The painstakingly crafted Neapolitan pies—cracker-thin crust with a pleasing char and a subtle Parmesan zing—are widely considered among the city's best; dough is made fresh several times a day. To keep kids occupied during what feels like an interminable wait, point out the window boxes full of herbs used to flavor the sauce.

Totonno's Pizza
Photograph: Dominic Perri

2. Totonno's

Restaurants Pizza Coney Island

At Totonno’s—a Coney Island beacon since Anthony Pero opened its doors in 1924—the pizza de résistance is the top-notch white pie. Sand-dusted pizza lovers make the trek from the beach for the off-menu garlicky round: It’s covered in gleaming white house-made mozzarella and pecorino romano, leopard-spotted with crispy char marks. It’s the best thing on the menu, and given delicious alternatives, like the purist Margherita pie, that’s saying something. 

Advertising

3. Lucali

Restaurants Pizza Carroll Gardens

The artisanal intent at the candlelit pizzeria is visible in the flour-dashed marble counter where the dough is punched and stretched, and in the brick oven from which it later emerges crisp and blistered. There are just two items on Lucali’s menu: pies and calzones, adorned with milky, elastic mozzarella and simple toppings like chewy rounds of pepperoni or slivers of artichoke. There’s no wine list, but the unobtrusive staff will happily extract a cork from your own bottle.

Franny's
Photograph: Virginia Rollison

4. Franny’s

Restaurants Pizza Prospect Heights

The sweet smell of smoke greets diners—and sticks to their hair and clothes—at this insta-classic. Thin, bubbly, locavore pizzas are the soul of this operation, helmed by husband-and-wife team Francine Stephens and Andrew Feinberg (Savoy). A sausage-and-cheese pie isn’t just a cravings-sater—it’s a work of art. The chewy, charred pizza, with coins of funky house-cured meat, buffalo mozzarella and fragrant Parmesan cheeses, a sauce that’s so sweet it reminds you that tomatoes are fruit, plus a drizzle of olive oil, is among the city’s best. 

Advertising

5. Roberta's

Restaurants Pizza East Williamsburg

Buzzing with urban-farming fund-raisers, local brewers pouring their ales and food-world luminaries fresh off Heritage Radio interviews, this sprawling hangout has become the unofficial meeting place for Brooklyn's sustainable-food movement. Opened in 2008 by Chris Parachini, Brandon Hoy and Carlo Mirarchi, Roberta's features its own rooftop garden, a food-focused Internet-radio station and a kitchen that turns out pizzas—like the Cheesus Christ, topped with mozzarella, Taleggio, Parmesan, black pepper and cream—that are among the borough's best.

L&B Spumoni square pie
Photograph: Melissa Sinclair

6. L&B Spumoni Gardens

Restaurants Pizza Gravesend

Since 1939, this Bensonhurst original—where muscle-bound Brooklynites with deep accents gather in the outdoor patio—has served one of the best Sicilian slices in town. Candy-sweet tomato sauce is generously slathered over tall, doughy rectangles with a crunchy browned bottom. It’s finished with squares of melted mozzarella and zippy strands of Parm.

Advertising
Emily's
Photograph: Courtesy Jill Futter

7. Emily

Restaurants Pizza Clinton Hill

The heat of the wood-fired oven welcomes you into the cozy dining space, indicative of the charred crusts and inventive toppings to come. The pizza, categorized by sauce color, is the star of the show. From the Red column comes the Camp Randall ($19), an idyllically charred crust topped with tomato sauce, sausage, mushrooms, peppers and cheddar curds. It’s an update to the pies you ate in your youth, savory from the sausage and perhaps a bit squeaky (in the best way) from the curds. The namesake White pizza, the Emily ($22), surrounds you like a hug—topped with mozzarella, pistachios, truffle sottocenere and honey, it’s a performance in restraint.

8. Juliana's

Restaurants Pizza Brooklyn Heights

Patsy Grimaldi—the flour-dusted legend behind Grimaldi's, which has since changed hands—busts out of retirement to reclaim his pie shop's first location, along with its original coal oven. The octogenarian pizzaiolo–who learned to spin dough at age 13 in his Uncle Patsy Lancieri's Harlem institution—named the spot after his mother. The menu spotlights iconic red-sauce fare, including classic pies (Margherita, sausage and broccoli rabe), appetizers (eggplant rollatine, baked clams with parsley) and desserts (cannoli), but the New York icon mixed in a few nods to modern times, like a bagel-riffing pie made with lox and mascarpone. 

Advertising

9. Paulie Gee's

Restaurants Pizza Greenpoint

Pizza hobbyist turned pro Paul Giannone produces truly original pies at this rustic Greenpoint eatery. The best pizzas here are mixed-media masterworks with gorgeously blackened crusts covered in crispy nooks and pillowy bubbles. The Cherry Jones—featuring honey from a Brooklyn beekeeper, Gorgonzola, mozzarella, cherries and wispy prosciutto—beautifully balances sweet and salty. The Whiter Shade of Kale sees a nut-free kale pesto fired atop gooey mozzarella. Ask for a seat in the back for a view of the roaring oven—a custom-built, while-tiled dome that burns up to 1,000 degrees.

10. Speedy Romeo

Restaurants American Clinton Hill

Wood-fired cooking arrives in Clinton Hill via this Italian-inspired tavern. Watch Jean Georges vet Justin Bazdarich work the flames at the log-fueled grill and oven as he dispatches smoke-kissed pizzas, steaks and seafood from an open kitchen. The simple menu also includes small plates, like fresh homemade mozzarella, aioli-drizzled mussels and market salads. Drinkers can choose from eight draft beers, an extensive selection of canned beers (Narrangansett, 21st Amendment), and Italian and American wines. Tools, parts and equipment from the former occupant, an automotive shop, decorate the 60-seat space.

Show more

Looking for more amazing Italian food?

Recommended

    You may also like

      Advertising