Les Miserables mash up, 2020
Colm Wilkinson (original 1985 Jean Valjean) and Jon Robyns (current 2020 Jean Valjean)

Does ‘Les Mis’ still matter?

Returning revamped after a brief hiatus, ‘Les Misérables’ is back for a record-setting thirty-fifth year in the West End. But does it still stand up?

Andrzej Lukowski
Advertising

‘You are not asked to like “Les Misérables”. You are asked to admire it.’

So declared former Time Out theatre editor Susie MacKenzie in a terse third-of-a-column review of a musical that opened at the Barbican in October 1985 (no star rating, we were too highbrow back then).

It’s now part of the myth of  ‘Les Misérables’ – enthusiastically burnished by its lead producer Cameron Mackintosh – that the critics hated it but the public lapped it up, propelling it to world dominance on the back of pure people power. In fact, the reviews were mixed and McKenzie’s response is typical: the musical – a co-production between Mackintosh and the RSC – was so disorientingly bombastic that reviewers seemed a bit dazed and confused by the whole thing. This was long before ‘Les Misérables’ became ‘Les Mis’, and nobody had any inkling it would go on to become the longest-running London musical of all time.

That’s exactly what Trevor Nunn’s production of Alain Boublil and Claude-Michel Schönberg’s all-singing Victor Hugo adaptation became, though. Following Jean Valjean – a humble French peasant who spends 19 years in jail then battles appalling odds to make something of his life – ‘Les Mis’ has become a true London icon. It hopped from its short stint at the Barbican to 19 years at the Palace Theatre, then on to a further 15 at the Queen’s Theatre. It’s been seen around the world – it’s the sixth-longest-running Broadway show of all time – but London is its real home, where it’s the longest-running musical ever. Maybe the stratospheric UK success of a show about the little-known Paris Uprising of 1832 is a sign that we’re a truly international city. Maybe it just proves that musical theatre – which lest we forget, also gave us ‘Starlight Express’ – is just pretty random.

Whatever the case, with still-ubiquitous tunes such as ‘One Day More’ and ‘I Dreamed a Dream’, ‘Les Mis’ has indeed experienced one day more, then another day more, then several thousand other days more. What’s its secret? Lots of things. There are undoubtedly some stone-cold bangers in the song list. Serious, emotional musicals tend to have more success than silly, lightweight ones, and ‘Les Mis’ is very, very serious. Success begets success: in part it’s popular because it’s now so famous. And Mackintosh has kept it in good order: it continues to makes use of world-class performers, and it’s been discreetly tweaked over the years, with the somewhat ’80s-tastic original score updated a few years back. The recent blockbuster film didn’t hurt either.

However. The last year has been the weirdest one in the show’s history, as – and you might want to take notes – the original production closed in July, to be temporarily replaced by a concert version, which has in turn been replaced by the ‘new’ version that’s been rolled out across the globe over the last few years, leaving London the last place in the world where you could catch Trevor Nunn’s RSC production. Cameron Mackintosh would like us to accept the ‘new’ version of ‘Les Mis’ as pure continuity, and although you can understand why Nunn is fuming, the fact is that Mackintosh has a point. As it turns out, the changes are fairly superficial: broadly speaking, the iconic revolving stage is out, some fancy new projections are in, and that’s about the size of it.

So why do it? A cynical soul would perhaps speculate that Mackintosh no longer wanted to share credit with the RSC, which had enjoyed a solid stream of revenue from the show over the last 34 years. But the superproducer is a notorious perfectionist, and we should probably take him at his word when he says that he sincerely thinks this is a better version.

The truth, though, is that while Mackintosh made ‘Les Misérables’, it is now much bigger than him, and I suspect he’d only dare tweak it so far. It is not just a musical. Here in London it is the musical, and it will live on a long time after its producer is gone – and perhaps the rest of us too.

‘Les Misérables’ is booking at the Sondheim Theatre until Oct 17.

More London musicals

  • Musicals
  • Strand
  • 3 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended

This long-gestating musical version of ‘Back to the Future’ is so desperate to please that the producers would doubtless offer a free trip back in time with every ticket purchase if the laws of physics allowed…

Where is it? Adelphi Theatre

  • Musicals
  • Whitehall

A quintessential ’90s high school comedy that launched the brief Hollywood career of Alicia Silverstone, Amy Heckerling’s 1995 ‘Clueless’ is a smart rewrite of Jane Austen’s ‘Emma’. Now it’s a musical, with Heckerling writing the book and big-in-the-’00s Scottish songwriter KT Tunstall doing the music, with direction from Rachel Kavanaugh.

Where is it? Trafalgar Theatre.

Advertising
  • Musicals
  • Seven Dials
  • 4 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended

A labour of love that has worked its way slowly to the West End over the five years since it debuted at Southwark Playhouse, at its best Jethro Compton’s The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is an extraordinary thing, a soaring folk opera that overwhelms you with a cascade of song and feeling.

Where is it? Ambassadors Theatre.

  • Musicals
  • Bloomsbury

The Devil Wears Prada had me flummoxed. It is an adaptation of the 2006 millennial classic about a mousy young journalism graduate who blunders into the job of PA to a tyrannical, Anna Wintour-alike fashion editor. The songs are by none other than Elton John, with lyrics by Shania Taub and Mark Sonnenblick. The director-choreographer is Broadway veteran Jerry Mitchell. There’s some serious talent involved. And yet being turned into a musical does… almost nothing for it.

Where is it? Dominion Theatre.

Advertising
  • Musicals
  • Covent Garden

F Scott Fitzgerald’s classic novella about the dark side of the American Dream has been endlessly adapted for the stage and that’s kicked into overdrive now that the US copyright has expired – there are two big US musical adaptations. Here’s the first: a year after it opened on the Great White Way, The Great Gatsby will transfer to London, playing the limited summer season at the huge London Coliseum.

Where is it? London Coliseum.

Advertising
  • Musicals
  • Shaftesbury Avenue
  • 4 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended

What a long, strange trip it’s been. Indie-folk musician Anaïs Mitchell’s musical retelling of the Orpheus story began life in the mid-’00s as a lo-fi song cycle – going through the next 14 years blow-by-blow would be time-consuming, but in short thanks to what I can only describe as THEATRE MAGIC, Hadestown is now a full-blown musical directed by the visionary Rachel Chavkin, its success as a show vastly outstripping that of the record.

Where is it? Lyric Theatre.

  • Musicals
  • VictoriaOpen run
  • 5 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended
Hamilton
Hamilton

Okay, let’s just get this out of the way. ‘Hamilton’ is stupendously good…

Where is it? Apollo Victoria.

Advertising
  • Musicals
  • Covent Garden

Occupying the gap left by the mighty Frozen at the huge Theatre Royal Drury Lane, Hercules is a fascinating choice of Disney film for the megacorp to adapt as its new stage musical…

Where is it? Theatre Royal Drury Lane.

Advertising
  • Musicals
  • Tower Bridge

The second musical to be staged at the Bridge is a revival of the late, great Stephen Sondheim’s Into the Woods, his puckish musical subversion of the Brothers Grimm fairytales. The show will be directed by Jordan Fein, an American making a serious name for himself over here thanks to his excellent 2024 Regent’s Park Open Air Theatre revival of Fiddler on the Roof

Where is it? Bridge Theatre.

  • Musicals
  • Shaftesbury Avenue
  • 3 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended

If you’re in the market for sexy rearrangements of AOR smashes combined with a hagiographic account of Bob Geldof’s Band Aid and Live Aid projects, then boy are you going to love ‘Just for One Day’, which transfers to the West End after success at the Old Vic in 2024.

Where is it? Shaftesbury Theatre.

Advertising
  • West End
  • South Bank
  • Recommended

The National Theatre’s extraordinary verbatim musical returns for a very limited run as part of Rufus Norris’s final season in charge of the iconic venue.

Where is it? National Theatre.

  • Musicals
  • Soho
  • 4 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended
Les Misérables
Les Misérables

Les Mis could be transposed to space, or underwater, or to the height of the Hittite empire and it would basically be the same show as long as the singing was on point.

Where is it? Sondheim Theatre.

Advertising
  • Musicals
  • Seven Dials
  • 4 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended
Matilda the Musical
Matilda the Musical

'Matilda' must be making its creators, playwright Dennis Kelly and comedian-songsmith Tim Minchin, a very pair of proud parents.

Where is it? Cambridge Theatre.
Advertising
Advertising
  • Musicals
  • Soho
  • 3 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended

The friend who was supposed to come with me to ‘Moulin Rouge! The Musical’ dropped out because of a migraine, and honestly, hard relate: director Alex Timbers’s dementedly maximalist ‘remix’ of Baz Luhrmann’s smash 2001 film is pure sensory overload…

Where is it? Piccadilly Theatre.

Advertising
  • Musicals
  • St James’s
  • 4 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended
The Phantom of the Opera
The Phantom of the Opera

I’m not sure any show ‘deserves’ to be the most successful entertainment event of all time, but I’ll hand it current holder of that title, ‘The Phantom of the Opera’ – it still works hard for its audience.

Where is it? His Majesty’s Theatre.

  • Musicals
  • Charing Cross Road
  • 4 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended

Last seen in London almost 18 years ago, it’s easy to forget what a phenomenon The Producers was at the time - easily the most hyped musical of the century until the emergence of Hamilton. And it was a coup for the tiny Menier to have scored the first London revival of the show – now it transfers to the West End.

Where is it? Garrick Theatre.

Advertising
  • Musicals
  • Regent’s Park

Shucked is a superb way to kick off Drew McOnie’s tenure at the OAT: it’s the UK premiere for Robert Horn, Brandy Clark and Shane McAnally’s multi Tony-nominated 2022 musical comedy about a comically isolated rural farming community which must send representatives to the big city after their corn crop starts to fail. US director Jack O’Brien will restage his smash show with a new, UK cast. 

Where is it? Regent’s Park Open Air Theatre.

  • Musicals
  • Strand
  • 3 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended
Six the Musical
Six the Musical

‘Remember us from your GCSEs? It’s Henry VIII’s six wives – and they’ve back, bitch, to re-tell ‘her-story’ as a slick, sassy girl band. Think Euro-pop remixes of ‘Greensleeves’, Anne Boleyn spouting tweenage text-speak (‘everybody chill/it’s totes God’s will’), and K-Howard warbling #MeToo tales of gropey employers.

Advertising
  • Musicals
  • Wembley
  • 3 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended

Quite possibly the most aggressively ‘80s artefact in existence, Andrew Lloyd Webber’s ‘Starlight Express’ is a musical about anthropomorphic roller skating trains that often feels like being forced to watch ten consecutive episodes of some trashy Saturday morning action cartoon…

Where is it? Troubadour Wembley Park Theatre.

  • Musicals
  • Piccadilly Circus
  • 3 out of 5 stars
  • Recommended

While the RMS Titanic proved to be all too sinkable, this titanically camp musical spoof of the James Cameron film should sail on for quite some time. Or at least it will if its manifest target audience  – unsubtly shouted out to as ‘gays’ at least twice during the show – is as enthusiastic for it here as in New York, where it’s been sitting pretty off-Broadway since 2022.

Where is it? Criterion Theatre.

Advertising
Recommended
    London for less
      You may also like
      You may also like
      Advertising