[category]
[title]
Going strong for more than eight years, Bistecca from the Liquid & Larder team is a restaurant I’d be proud to take any out-of-towner to

I’m very lucky (#blessed) that part of my role as editor of Time Out Sydney is getting to eat out. A lot. Probably too much.
But just like you, I still have places on my dining bucket list. Lumi, the Italian-Japanese restaurant in a glass box on Pyrmont's wharf, is one of them. Sixpenny and Porteño are two others.
Bistecca, the underground steak restaurant from the Liquid & Larder group (also behind Alfie's, The Rover and The Gidley), was on that list, too. I finally went recently. And I know we're not at the end-of-year, let's-blast-Mariah-Carey stage just yet, but I'll say it served the best steak I’ve had in Sydney – and one of the most memorable meals I've had this year.
Years ago, co-owners James Bradey and Warren Burns were dining in Montepulciano when a waiter told them, “Staccate i telefoni”. They enjoyed meals without their phones for the rest of the holiday and decided to open Bistecca the same way. In July 2018, they did exactly that, opening an Italian steakhouse in a bunker-style basement in Sydney’s CBD.
When you sit down, a box is placed on your table for you to pop your phone into. It’s locked away safely until you’re ready to head back into the world. For someone who is always on their phone, having it taken away, completely out of my control, was like a big exhale. A bit like Savasana at the end of yoga practice – but with fewer leggings and more wine.
Because phones are locked away, there are only a handful of photos of the dining room – and no viral, same-same Instagram videos about it being Sydney’s ‘hidden gem’ – so stepping inside is a delight. Black-and-white chequered flooring, an exposed brick domed ceiling and another painted duck-egg blue. Vintage knick-knacks and artworks dotted all around. Each table covered in butcher’s paper. A fire burns in the hearth; one chef butchering and weighing cuts all evening.
There’s only one steak on the menu of this steakhouse: bistecca alla Fiorentina. The Tuscan T-bone is loved for its hefty size, caramelised crust and simple seasonings.
Here at Bistecca, the chefs, led by executive chef Pip Pratt, use Riverine Black Angus from the NSW Riverina region, which is wet-aged for up to eight weeks in Liquid & Larder's in-house butchery at Alfie's, before being dried for up to five more days so the surface gets an even crust.
You pick your weight, with the minimum order being 600g, and it’s priced at $22 per 100g. We were recommended to go for 750g (noting the bone weighs a bit). One of the chefs butchers the cut before a waiter presents it at the table, writes our order on the butcher’s paper and takes it back to the chefs to cook over ironbark and charcoal.
Once rested, the chefs carve it off the bone and baste it in beef tallow. It arrives with a perfectly caramelised char, accompanied by a lemon cheek. No mustard, mushrooms or gravy. The meat is pink and tender, with so much beefy flavour, the fat heavenly and the seasoning taken right to the edge. A squeeze of lemon brings lift and brightness. At one point, my partner picks up the bone and our waiter laughs, saying that makes him happy. The steak is close-your-eyes excellent – the best I’ve had in Sydney.
Elsewhere, a well-dressed radicchio, pear, caramelised pecan and gorgonzola salad hits all the right sweet, bitter, salty, crunchy and creamy notes. A potato dish, all paper-thin, golden layers, alongside a creamy Parmesan sauce, is killer. And our starters – beetroot-cured kingfish with cultured cream and sorrel; and bone marrow and prosciutto crust – were enjoyable. But the star of the show is the steak and if you only ordered that you'd leave happy.
This is backed up by personable, polished service, and delicious Italian wines, curated by head sommelier Sheila Richter. And that dining room that makes you feel like you’re in some other place, some other time.
Wait, did I mention the candle? I'll let you discover that one for yourself.
At one point, I sat back and thought: this is a restaurant I'd be proud to bring anyone from Melbourne, or overseas, to. So unlike anything else we have in Sydney. How cool that we have it.
Looking around the packed room, each guest in their own silo of conversation, not a bright glow from a phone to be seen, it’s clear the guys were onto something back in 2018. The 50-seat dining room often books out 30 days ahead, with a weekend waitlist of up to 700 (!), so it’s still very much working.
I am already looking forward to going back. Better set my alarm.
Book via SevenRooms up to 30 days ahead, with new tables released daily at 7am. Find out more here.
Note, I was hosted by Bistecca, but our editorial recommendations are always honest. Find out more, here.
Stay in the loop: sign up for our free Time Out Sydney newsletter for more news, food & drink inspo and activity ideas, straight to your inbox.
Discover Time Out original video