Winner: Saint Peter
An unassuming Paddington restaurant heralds a new age in Australian seafood dining – and we’re hooked
Josh Niland is a specialist. While other chefs were jumping from Chinese kitchens into classic French bistros, he stayed the course under mentors Peter Doyle and Steve Hodges until his seafood skills reached Jedi-like heights. Then he went and opened the restaurant Sydney needed: one devoted wholly and exclusively to the fruits of the sea. If it does not swim, crawl or breathe under the ocean, it’s not on the menu here. We love Saint Peter for its singular focus. There is no dilution of the core tenet, no reluctant steak for people who are funny about fish. Hell, even their brunch menu is a pescatarian dream. While it’s true that they do the finest fish and chips in town, save the safe order for another night when you’re getting takeaway from their Fish Butchery up the road. Instead, order a tangle of octopus legs that are punked up with a feisty XO and silky squid ink giving those firm cephalopod limbs a luxe-goth sheen.
How do you make Murray cod feel like a Sunday roast you’d serve to a vicar? It’s all down to the rosemary swimming through an earthy, wintery vegetable broth and Jerusalem artichokes cooked down until they’re almost a sweet paste. On top of this rustic plinth rests the creamiest fillet of medium rare cod imaginable and together this dish produces the kind of warm trance state you enter when sitting near an open fire. It doesn’t last long, because the Bass groper curry is loaded with so much Meyer lemon zest it’s like an ice bath for your senses. The mix of garlic, ginger, native turmeric leaf, native ginger, pepperberry and native thyme is a 21-gun salute to strong flavours, but the secret is the whole smoked eel that is blended in for that round, rich savouriness. You’re here to eat seafood, talk about seafood; rank your favourite seafood and then go home, warm in the knowledge that you just had the best fish dinner in Sydney.
We also love...
This stalwart of the Sydney aspirational dining scene is still kicking goals under the watchful eye of chef Joel Bickford.
At this high end beach club house you can live like you’re famous, with a whole lobsters on the coals and Champagne on ice.
Kylie Kwong takes her Chinese heritage and fuses it with Australian native ingredients.
The woodfired oven in this eatery is responsible for some of the most delicious snack action in town.
Their lamb leg has reached legendary status, and you can eat it in the kitchen.
This underground French bistro has completely flipped the definition of CBD dining.
Anywhere you can get steamed pipis for brunch is always going to be on our hit list.
It’s a five-star fine diner hiding in the Inner West.
Vegetables have never tasted as good as they do at this high-end, meat free diner.