The best burgers in NYC

From classic cheeseburgers and smashed stacks to unconventional favorites, these are the best burgers in NYC.

Photograph: Courtesy Paul Wagtouicz

Sun's out, bun's out, since we're talking the best burgers you can get in Gotham. We take our patties very seriously so prepare yourselves for our bucket list of burgers you can start eating your way through. We've got late-night diners, BBQ restaurants and NYC steakhouses all on the list with creations spanning from simple and cheeseless to towering with toppings (even one of the best veggie burgers made the cut).  Take a gander at our selection and see if your favorites made the list.

RECOMMENDED: All of NYC's best burgers

The top burgers in New York

1

Black Label Burger at Minetta Tavern

Yes, it’s really 33 bucks, and yes, it’s cheeseless. But it's still our favorite, what with nine succulent ounces of prime-grade, dry-aged rib eye, skirt steak and brisket from carne king Pat LaFrieda to distract you. If that’s not enough, the caramelized-to-a-melt onions and seeded Balthazar brioche should seal the deal. $33.

Book now Read more
Greenwich Village
2

The Emmy Burger at Emily Pizza

Though it’s a stellar pizza joint, the best thing on the menu may just be the burger. Made with a dry-aged beef patty on a pretzel bun with caramelized onions, cheddar and a heavenly concoction called Emmy sauce, this burger deserves all the hype, and then some. ($27)

Read more
Clinton Hill
Advertising
3

Double ShackBurger at Shake Shack

Debuting as a Madison Square Park hot-dog cart in 2004, Shake Shack has evolved into an internation burger powerhouse. Thin patties of a proprietary Pat LaFrieda blend (brisket, chuck and short rib) are shellacked with tangy ShackSauce and American cheese before getting nestled in a griddled potato bun for a classed-up classic. $8.09.

Read more
Flatiron
4

Le Big Matt at Emmy Squared

Matt and Emily Hyland managed to follow up their Emmy Burger with another noteworthy creation, this time at their Detroit-style pizza spot in Williamsburg. Le Big Matt takes a double-stack of Pat Lafrieda beef patties and tops it with American cheese, greens and pickles. It gives you those nostalgic fast food-vibes, but classed-up (especially with the side serving of waffle fries). $25.

Read more
Williamsburg
Advertising
5

Cheeseburger at J.G. Melon

It’s an oldie but def a goody: The corner tavern has been flipping some of the best burgers in town since 1972. Griddled diner-style on a flattop, the eight-ounce, medium-rare beaut is served open-faced with melted American cheese on a lightly toasted bun with the classic fixings. $12.50.

Read more
Lenox Hill
6

‘21’ Burger at 21 Club

The 21 Club may seem a little stuffy with a dress code requiring men wear jackets or the dated decor of miniature planes and sports memorabilia hanging from the ceiling but it's sure worth going for the ‘21’ Burger: A massive, perfectly-cooked patty is served in a fluffy brioche bun with pickled relish and fries. $36.

Book now Read more
Midtown West
Advertising
7

Luger Burger at Peter Luger

Recommended

A steakhouse landmark, Peter Luger knows as thing or two about beef. So it's no surprise that they make a killer burger, stacking over 1/2-pound of beef on a bun. While you can add American cheese or a thick slice of bacon, we're perfectly happy with keeping it simple, especiall when it tastes so good. $14.95.

Read more
Williamsburg
8

The Classic Cheeseburger at Donovan’s Pub

Classic is right. Both this Irish-accented corner bar and its burger have been Queens fixtures since 1966, and the sandwich is as refreshingly no-fuss as the rest of the wood-paneled joint. The charbroiled half-pounder is humbly topped with lettuce and tomato. All that's missing is a pint of Guinness. $10.95.

Read more
Woodside
Advertising
9

USC Burger at Union Square Cafe

Recommended

While Union Square Cafe has gone through a reboot, luckily their burger has not. A juicy blend of shortrib and brisket is cooked to a perfect medium-rare and covered in cheddar and bacon. With a balance of smoke, tang and, well, beefiness, this burger is clear choice for your next power lunch. $29.

Read more
Gramercy
10

American Cheeseburger at 4 Charles Prime Rib

The NYC-counterpart to the Chicago's famous Au Cheval, 4 Charles Prime Rib offers a near replica of the widely acclaimed burger without a trip to the Windy City. The griddle-smashed patties are crowned with plastic-wrap American cheese and the option to stack on a fried egg or slabs of maple-glazed bacon. $19.95.

Read more
West Village
Advertising
Show more

See the best burgers in America

Comments

7 comments
Ken M

Sorry, Bareburger beats nearly every burger on this list. Shakeshack? Burger Joint? They're okay, I guess. Another demi-chain you forgot is The Capital Grille. Their Wagyu burger - served only for a couple months a year - is an event worth anticipating. 

Enrique G

Shake shack suckass!!! Basic burger

Edmond V

I don't think that there is anything that I like more than a good burger. I'm going out to NYC in a couple of days, and I'm going to have to try a couple of these places out for sure. I think that the steak burger at Eats looks amazing as well. There is so much meat on that, it's going to be awesome. 

Mark L

Gaelic Burger @ Nelly Spillanes 33rd Street

Harry R

How can Jackson Hole not be there!!!

Randall L

What a joke - minetta follows dram shop?!?!

Dram shop's burger is garbage, worse than a Big Mac at McDonald's.

Timeout, you have no credibility any more. Goodbye.

Mgardner25

This is last years list... wheres the winners from this years?