Meet your contenders for Battle of the Burger 2016

This summer, vote on your favorite patty melt or huge hunk of meat to win for this year's Battle of the Burger

Photograph: Nick Murway

There's never a wrong time to eat a burger. Whether you want a cheap smash patty for lunch or late-night dining or you're looking for a fancy and juicy upscale version, Chicago's got a burger for you. This year, we're leaving it up to you to pick the best. Meet the 50 beefy contenders for Chicago's Battle of the Burger.

RECOMMENDED: Our guide to the Battle of the Burger

Acadia Burger at Acadia

With three cuts of beef (chuck as the base, brisket for juiciness, Wagyu scraps for fat), two types of cheese (Gruyère, Mornay sauce) and a bottomless reserve of umami (bacon-onion jam, house-made pickles), it's clear this burger has been obsessed over by chef Ryan McCaskey. All those delicious details are what make diners obsess over it, too. $18. —David Tamarkin

Book now Read more
Near South Side

Patty Melt at Appellation

One of two patty melts on this list, this one's mostly meat, topped with a smoked onion confit and cheese. While the patty is the star of the show, its minimal accoutrements turn it into a pretty solid burger. $13. —Elizabeth Atkinson

Book now Read more
Andersonville
Advertising

Single Cheeseburger at Au Cheval

The two thin patties (a "single" is really a double here) aren't the star of this much-obsessed-over burger. Instead it's the generous schmear of mayo, the melted American cheese and the chopped raw onions that cut through the beef with a piquant bite. $10.95. —DT

Read more
West Loop

The Bad Apple Burger at The Bad Apple

A thick, juicy patty dominates opposite a toasted and chewy pretzel bun. Add melty provolone, LTO and pickles, and this burger's a picture-perfect example of how great a non-griddle burger can be. You could pick any meat burger on this menu and have the same meaty experience, but just make sure you ask for a pretzel bun. $10. —EA

Read more
North Center
Advertising

Burger at Beef & Barley

This is a burger that you truly can't set down for a few reasons. It's on a biscuit, making any chance of reassembly nearly impossible and it's also probably the cause of your impending heart attack. Topped with Merkts cheese, two fried onion rings, red onions, caramelized onions and pickles, it's a mouthful, but it's also the ultimate comfort burger. $10. —EA

Read more
Lake View

Pimiento Cheese Burger at Big Jones

The steamed bun prevents the mess of two thin, juicy patties slathered with creamy, spicy house-made pimiento cheese and a heap of griddled onions from dripping onto your plate. You don't want even a morsel of this burger to go anywhere but in your mouth. $13.—Laura Baginski

Book now Read more
Andersonville
Advertising

Grilled Short Rib Burger at Blackbird

The two-inch-thick patty made with short rib from deli/butcher Publican Quality Meats is the star: The meat is velvety, juicy and, true to its origins, screams quality. Toppings change often, but on my visit, mimolette "Velveeta" takes a backseat to pickled ramps and beef-cheek jam, all on a sesame brioche bun. $15. — Laura Baginski

Book now Read more
West Loop

Ground Bacon Burger at Bottlefork

“It’s 70-percent beef, 30-percent bacon,” our server proudly proclaimed of the patty. Honestly, I couldn’t care less whether the bacon infusion was responsible for the patty’s dripping juiciness or distinct umami flavor. All I know is, the burger, topped with micro shoestring potatoes, pungent blue cheese and a “special sauce,” is eyes-roll-back-in-your-head good. — Laura Baginski

Book now Read more
River North
Advertising

BRGRBELLY at BRGRBELLY

There are many tempting options on this Portage Park burger joint’s menu, including sandwiches topped with crab cakes, Polish sausage and chili cheese Fritos. Frankly, you’re better off ordering the basic BRGRBELLY burger—it’s a simple cheeseburger that allows you to enjoy the patty’s flavorful blend of ground chuck and smoked pork belly without being distracted by decadent toppings. The burger is served with house-made sriracha pickles and your choice of cheese on a hearty sesame seed bun that’s baked in-house. Every sandwich comes with a free butter cookie, so make sure to save room for dessert.​ —ZL

Read more
Portage Park

Natural & Local House Blend Beef at Butcher & the Burger

Allen Sternweiler’s adorable burger joint doubles as a butcher shop. It’s a DIY affair: Customers pick their meat, bun, spice rub and toppings before the burger is made to order. If you stick to beef, go with “Grandma’s onion soup” rub and flank your burger with an order of the accomplished fries—you’ll be glad you did. Tack on a scoop of the house-made custard, and you’ll be even happier.

Book now Read more
Lincoln Park
Advertising

House Burger at Catalpa Kitchen

This Logan Square spot serves up a wealth of classic American dishes and crowd–pleasing favorites, like the burger. It's an 8-ounce patty topped with white cheddar and a dill pickle, a great choice before starting on your Saturday afternoon Logan Square bar crawl. $14.

Read more
Logan Square

CCR Prime Triple Cheese Burger at Cherry Circle Room

Chef Pete Coenen pairs two thin char-griddled patties—and trust me, you'll taste the char—with bread and butter pickles, smoked gouda, caramelized onion and horseradish mustard aioli to create this monster of a cheeseburger. The lettuce and tomato give it height, making this one a mouthful any way you cut it. $16. —EA

Book now Read more
Loop
Advertising

Burger at Commonwealth Tavern

Commonwealth, the gastropub Roscoe Village didn’t know it needed, serves a very simple burger—a half-pound patty, Hooks cheddar, bacon, house-made pickles and brioche bun. It’s perfectly executed and so delicious it’s worth a trip across town to get your hands on. Do yourself a favor and get the margarita, too. $12. —LB

Read more
North Center

Double Cheeseburger at Community Tavern

There are two burgers on the menu at Community Tavern, the bacon cheeseburger on the bar menu and the double cheeseburger on the dinner menu. Order the double cheeseburger, because while it (appropriately) doubles in price, it's leaps and bounds above the bar burger. With two beef patties, Hooks cheddar, pickles, carmelized onions and a side of house frites, it's bigger and well worth the extra scratch. $16. —EA

Read more
Portage Park
Advertising

Burger at Corridor Brewery & Provisions

The burger at Corridor Brewery & Provisions is a mouthful—a big, cut-in-half and still struggle mouthful. But it's delicious, with two steak patties, mustard herb mayo, melty cheddar, Detroit pickles all on top of a chewy sesame seed bun. Double points: You can get this one all day long. —EA

Read more
Lake View

The Dawson Burger at The Dawson

The Dawson's large location can be daunting, but the patio is always a good bet. It's one of the most gorgeous in the city—sprawling and perfect for a summer brunch packed with drinks from the bar. The food is American and the place feels like it's pretty much always open (evenings and open for brunch and dinner on the weekend), making it an easy choice in West Town to gather with friends.

Book now Read more
River West/West Town
Advertising

No. 4 at DMK Burger Bar

Creative (but never overdone) toppings make the smashed-patty burgers at DMK sing. Try the No. 4, with roasted hatch green chili, Sonoma Jack cheese, smoked bacon and a fried egg. For $3, make it a double. The fries aren't to be overlooked either, and since they're available in two sizes, you'll be able to try two of the toppings without overdoing it. $10.50 single, $14.50 double.

Read more
Lake View

The Dove's Burger at Dove's Luncheonette

Dove's applies its winning Southern-Mexican theme to a diner burger, which is only available on weekdays starting at 11am until it's gone. The result is a spin on a patty melt, with sharp cheddar, a smoky pepper relish and creamy aioli packed between sourdough. It doesn't come with a side, so split an order of the fried potato and shishito pepper hash with your date. Just don't split the burger—you want this whole thing to yourself. $10. —AC

Read more
Wicker Park
Advertising

Burger at DryHop Brewers

The burger at DryHop remains one of the best: The brisket and sirloin patty is spread with ancho chile–tomato jam and creamy raw milk cheddar, with pickled onions to cut through the fat and arugula to lighten things up a bit. This is one balanced, beautiful burger.—AC

Read more
Lake View

Juicy Lucy at Dusek's Board and Beer

Invented in Minneapolis, the Juicy Lucy is a burger for anyone who prefers their cheese encased in beef instead of melted on top. The Dusek’s version stuffs American cheese into a Slagel Farm patty and tops it with butter lettuce and preserved tomatoes. The best addition to the burger is a red onion and bacon marmalade, which gives each bite a smoky-yet-sweet flavor. It’s served with a heaping portion of duck fat fries you can dig into while you wait for the burger’s molten cheese core to cool. $15. ​—Zach Long

Book now Read more
Lower West Side
Advertising
Show more

Single Cheeseburger at Fairways

I love a burger straight off the grill, and Fairways tastes like a smoky backyard burger that's been elevated with melted American cheese, LTO, pickles and dijonnaise. You’ll get a choice of frites, chips or salad on the side—the frites, cooked in duck fat and with a shake of truffle salt, is the only answer. $10. —AC

Read more
Lincoln Park

Pasture Raised "Classic" at Farm Bar

There are five burgers on the menu at this Midwestern spot—the Classic, the Barnyard, Three Sisters, Harvest and Trippel. They range from the weird (the Three Sisters has popcorn on it, giving it a crunch not normally associated with burgers) to the expected (the Classic boasts lettuce, tomato, onion and cheddar). Regardless of which one you pick, the burger will be cooked nicely, and you'll leave pleased. $13-$16. — EA

Read more
Lake View
Advertising

Feast Burger at Feast

The first flavor that jumps out on the Feast burger is the generous slathering of red onion marmalade, which adds a sweet and rich caramelized onion flavor. The single burger is nestled in a brioche bun and topped with an extra creamy Saint-André cheese. Arugula and dijonnaise round out the flavor, but with 70-percent butterfat, the cheese is the secret sauce that makes this burger totally addictive. $14. —Martha Williams

Read more
Wicker Park

Burger at Forbidden Root

Topped with aged cheddar, a hefty helping of crunchy giardiniera mayo and a bread and butter pickle, the burger at Forbidden Root is unique but familiar. The perfectly salty eight-ounce beef patty is tempered by all the toppings. Don't forget to eat the crispy fries that come with it—we almost ordered seconds. $14. —EA

Book now Read more
East Village
Advertising

Prez Obama Burger at Good Stuff Eatery

When DC Top Chef alum Spike Mendelsohn opened the first Chicago outpost of his casual burger joint, he airlifted the menu straight from DC. That explains the name of the Prez Obama burger, which made its Chicago debut last fall when it won the Hamburger Hop contest at Chicago Gourmet. And this is a winning burger—it hits all the right notes and textures, from sweet onion marmalade to salty bacon to sharp Roquefort and pungent horseradish mayo. $7.25. —AC

Read more
Loop

Cheeseburger at GreenRiver

Cooking the meat correctly is crucial to constructing a good burger, and GreenRiver puts together a mean one. It sports a thick patty, with just the right amount of pinkness in the middle, melting cheddar cheese, briny pickles and a house sauce to tie the whole thing together. $21. —EA

Book now Read more
Streeterville
Advertising

Double Cheese Burger at Fries at Haywood Tavern

Haywood Tavern’s double cheeseburger isn’t exactly groundbreaking (what burger is?), but it’s an extremely solid rendition of the venerable dish, boasting two Slagel Farm beef patties, a tangy dijon aioli and just the right amount of crisp pickles. Served with fries, it’s the right size for a not-overly-hearty meal or a late-night snack, leaving you with enough room for a beer or cocktail at the Humboldt Park bar. $14. —ZL

Read more
Humboldt Park

Kimchi Burger at Howells & Hood

Cultures collide to make this burger great: Kimchi (Korean) provides the acidic bite, pickle aioli (French) offers creaminess, Gouda (Dutch) lends it a gooey, smoky flavor and the patty (we’re gonna go with American) is perfectly cooked. Hooray for globalization. —LB

Book now Read more
Streeterville
Advertising

Double Cheeseburger at Johnny's Grill

Double patties are a constant throughout this list, but the cheeseburger at Johnny's Grill departs from thin patties and instead stacks two medium patties with cheddar cheese dijonnaise, pickles and onion. It's a traditional diner burger, but with a bright saltiness that brings out the best in those huge hunks of meat. $9. —EA

Read more
Logan Square

Kuma Burger at Kuma’s Corner

The servers here sport more ink than a Bic factory, and the metal is cranked up so loud you can’t hear yourself talking, but therein lies the charm. Squeeze through the ass-to-elbows crowds and up to the long bar, where you might be in for a lengthy wait. What’s the draw? Well, the Slayer Burger, for one—a pile of fries topped with a half-pound burger, chili, cherry peppers, andouille, onions and Jack cheese on a pretzel bun. That, and the extensive menu of craft beers, including plenty of limited edition local brews to get before they’re gone.

Read more
Avondale
Advertising

Chicago Double at M Burger

Our current favorite on M Burger's lineup has to be the Chicago Double. It's a simple combination, with two juicy patties covered in American cheese, grilled onions, pickles and mustard. Are we in heaven? M Burger just put all of our favorite things on a single bun and now we don't know what else to eat for lunch. Seriously. $5.99 —EA

Read more
Loop

Downstairs Burger at Maple & Ash

You have to walk through the downstairs bar at Maple & Ash to get up to the second floor lounge, or you could just stop there and settle for a limited menu and drinks. If you do the latter, you can order the Downstairs Burger, piled with gooey cheese and onions—you should add some thick and tender bacon, too. You may feel classy sitting at Maple & Ash, but this burger is messy enough to bring you back down to earth (be careful not to stain your nice clothes). $14. —EA

Book now Read more
Rush & Division
Advertising

Hamburger at Mindy's HotChocolate

The house-ground Slagel beef burger arrives expertly cooked, christened with a cross of crispy bacon and a melting slice of aged cheddar tucked under a toasted, house-made sesame bun. Give it a few squirts of house-made ketchup and mustard, then layer on the in-house pickles. $14. —Lauren Viera

Read more
Wicker Park

Nico Burger at Nico Osteria

Our favorite among the trio of burgers on offer during Nico’s lunch and brunch services tastes like a Big Mac that’s been sent away to finishing school. A freshly ground blend of Slagel Farms chuck, short rib and sirloin makes for a patty of magnificent tenderness. The juices run and mingle with the tangy house-made Thousand Island dressing that tops it, eventually coming to rest within the crumb of a supremely soft potato bun. Shredded iceberg lettuce adds a pleasant crunch, while salty provolone contributes a note of umami funk. $14. —CH

Book now Read more
Gold Coast
Advertising

Burger at Owen & Engine

When this behemoth of an onion-studded potato bun hits your table, you'll vow to bring half home. Then you'll take one bite and realize no one has that kind of willpower. Beef this velvety is thanks to the fat in the blend—chuck with short rib and brisket. Wear stretchy pants. $16. —Marissa Conrad

Read more
Logan Square

Royale w/ Cheese at Pub Royale

Named after the infamous Pulp Fiction line, this British-Indian pub's Royale with Cheese is fantastic, despite sticking out like a sore thumb on the menu. Doubts are quickly dashed when this juicy hunk of a burger comes out with spicy pickles and melting cheddar. You'll want to order everything at Pub Royale, but you might want to include the burger near the top of that list. $14. —EA

Read more
Ukrainian Village
Advertising

Red Hot Ranch burger at Red Hot Ranch Lakeview

The second location of the late-night hot dog and fried shrimp joint is a little glitzier (televisions, seats), but the most important difference is that it also offers burgers, thin, griddled patties with perfectly melted cheese, LTO and special sauce. With fries, the double cheeseburger is less than $6, which makes the Red Hot Ranch Burger not only the best burger, but the best deal as well. $5.43.

Read more
Lake View

Blues Burger at River Roast

The caramelized onions, smoked ketchup and sliced blue cheddar (no crumbled blue here) are all layered on the brioche bun in perfect proportions, but it's the well-seasoned mix of chuck and brisket, which has a slight char on the edge, that steals all the glory. $14. —AC

Book now Read more
River North
Advertising

Rosebud Burger at Rosebud Steakhouse

An obnoxiously thick burger stabbed with a steak knife? Not at Rosebud, a steakhouse that shows restraint with its simple inch-thick patty layered with two slightly charred slices of American cheese, lettuce, tomato and pickles, all bookended with a toasted brioche bun. $14. —Laura Baginski

Book now Read more
Streeterville

Black Truffle Burger at RPM Steak

There are two burgers on the menu at RPM, but our server didn't hesitate on suggesting the truffle burger over the dry-aged steakburger. One bite, and it's clear why: The flavorful grass-fed beef comes with melting foie gras butter, truffle aioli and red onion jam. This is decadent, yes, but skip breakfast if you have to, as you're also going to want to go to town on the perfect fries, served with Caesar dressing for dipping. $17. —AC

Book now Read more
River North
Advertising

The Burger at Sidecar at LR

A burger pairs perfectly with a pint of beer, and at Sidecar at LR, it's pretty much a necessity. This burger from Beard & Belly has two thin but substantial patties with butterkäse cheese, pickles and special sauce. The pickle-filled bites are the best, but given how tender the meat is, it's easy to demolish the whole thing in a matter of seconds. $10. —Elizabeth Atkinson

Read more
Lake View

Burger at Small Cheval

As the name implies, this is an offshoot of Au Cheval, and the menu is inspired by the restaurant’s most famous item—the cheeseburger. This isn’t the exact same burger, but enumerating the differences feels like splitting hairs. It’s a little smaller and $1 cheaper. You can add bacon (it’s thinner than at Au Cheval), and lettuce and tomato, though the burger doesn’t need it. The super-thin patties themselves don’t add much flavor, but the perfectly melted cheese, Dijon, onion, pickles and puffy bun add up to a delicious combination. $8.95.

Read more
Wicker Park
Advertising

Hamburger Sandwich at The Duck Inn

Duck Inn chef Kevin Hickey is a master of bar food, and it only takes one bite of his hamburger to know it. With a healthy dose of grilled onions and a squeaky slice of Brun-uusto cheese, this is a soul-satisfying patty melt. — AC

Book now Read more
Bridgeport

The Melt at The Northman

Recommended

Served on a potato roll, this griddled patty covered in butterkäse, pickles and dark onions pairs well with a dry cider, a drink that is more abundant at the Northman than anywhere else in the city. It comes with fries and curried ketchup, which we would order again, even without the burger. $13. —EA

Read more
North Center
Advertising

1/4 Lb at Top Notch Beefburger

The Beverly neighborhood has a relaxed small-town-in-1965 feel, and one of the contributing reasons is this dose of Americana, both old enough and friendly enough to be your grandmother. The namesake burger is old-school minimalist, a deeply satisfying quarter-pound patty of fresh ground round sauteed in its own juices and served with the simplest toppings—grilled onions and ketchup-mustard-pickle on a feather-light bun. Just as good are the fresh-cut fries, cooked in beef tallow, and as long as you’re dining as if it’s 1965, finish up with a thick chocolate shake. $4.25.

Read more
Beverly

Torta de Hamburguesa at Topolobampo

Part of the recently revamped lunch menu at Rick Bayless's fine dining spot, this $19 burger is a juicy blend of ribeye and shortrib topped with chorizo. But wait, it gets more decadent: Melted cheddar coats the whole thing. Somehow, the roasted poblanos add enough acidity to keep this from becoming a gut bomb. It’s pricey, yes, so cut it in half and eat the rest for dinner, if that makes you feel better. $19. —LB

Book now Read more
River North
Advertising

Trench Double Burger at Trenchermen

Wizardry is the only explanation for the splendor of this bun: The potato dough–foccacia hybrid is impossibly light, yet—this is where the magic happens—it doesn't collapse, or even lose a touch of integrity, under the juiciness of the mind-bogglingly beefy and flavorful ground-in-house chuck patty, topped with pickles and cheddar. $16. —Julia Kramer

Read more
Wicker Park

The Burger at Untitled Supper Club

It may seem like your typical burger, but combined with a caraway brioche and house-smoked bacon, this burger is over the top. The cheddar and Coca-Cola onions contribute to a well-balanced flavor that is a departure from what you'll find on the rest of Untitled's new menu. $18. —EA

Read more
River North
Advertising

Burger at Whisk

Serving brunch by day and burgers by night, Whisk is a spot from brothers and chefs Rick and David Rodriguez. It's bright and lively with a sunny atmosphere—and the patio is littered with Ron Swanson memorabilia. Try the Chicago Avenue Burger, two thick patties topped with brisket, LTO, pickles and an onion ring.

Read more
Ukrainian Village

Comments

0 comments